November 30, 2010
By THOMAS L. FRIEDMAN
While secrets from WikiLeaks were splashed all over the American newspapers, I couldn’t help but wonder: What if China had a WikiLeaker and we could see what its embassy in Washington was reporting about America? I suspect the cable would read like this:
Washington Embassy, People’s Republic of China, to Ministry of Foreign Affairs Beijing, TOP SECRET/Subject: America today.
Things are going well here for China. America remains a deeply politically polarized country, which is certainly helpful for our goal of overtaking the U.S. as the world’s most powerful economy and nation. But we’re particularly optimistic because the Americans are polarized over all the wrong things.
There is a willful self-destructiveness in the air here as if America has all the time and money in the world for petty politics. They fight over things like — we are not making this up — how and where an airport security officer can touch them. They are fighting — we are happy to report — over the latest nuclear arms reduction treaty with Russia. It seems as if the Republicans are so interested in weakening President Obama that they are going to scuttle a treaty that would have fostered closer U.S.-Russian cooperation on issues like Iran. And since anything that brings Russia and America closer could end up isolating us, we are grateful to Senator Jon Kyl of Arizona for putting our interests ahead of America’s and blocking Senate ratification of the treaty. The ambassador has invited Senator Kyl and his wife for dinner at Mr. Kao’s Chinese restaurant to praise him for his steadfastness in protecting America’s (read: our) interests.
Americans just had what they call an “election.” Best we could tell it involved one congressman trying to raise more money than the other (all from businesses they are supposed to be regulating) so he could tell bigger lies on TV more often about the other guy before the other guy could do it to him. This leaves us relieved. It means America will do nothing serious to fix its structural problems: a ballooning deficit, declining educational performance, crumbling infrastructure and diminished immigration of new talent.
The ambassador recently took what the Americans call a fast train — the Acela — from Washington to New York City. Our bullet train from Beijing to Tianjin would have made the trip in 90 minutes. His took three hours — and it was on time! Along the way the ambassador used his cellphone to call his embassy office, and in one hour he experienced 12 dropped calls — again, we are not making this up. We have a joke in the embassy: “When someone calls you from China today it sounds like they are next door. And when someone calls you from next door in America, it sounds like they are calling from China!” Those of us who worked in China’s embassy in Zambia often note that Africa’s cellphone service was better than America’s.
But the Americans are oblivious. They travel abroad so rarely that they don’t see how far they are falling behind. Which is why we at the embassy find it funny that Americans are now fighting over how “exceptional” they are. Once again, we are not making this up. On the front page of The Washington Post on Monday there was an article noting that Republicans Sarah Palin and Mike Huckabee are denouncing Obama for denying “American exceptionalism.” The Americans have replaced working to be exceptional with talking about how exceptional they still are. They don’t seem to understand that you can’t declare yourself “exceptional,” only others can bestow that adjective upon you.
In foreign policy, we see no chance of Obama extricating U.S. forces from Afghanistan. He knows the Republicans will call him a wimp if he does, so America will keep hemorrhaging $190 million a day there. Therefore, America will lack the military means to challenge us anywhere else, particularly on North Korea, where our lunatic friends continue to yank America’s chain every six months so that the Americans have to come and beg us to calm things down. By the time the Americans do get out of Afghanistan, the Afghans will surely hate them so much that China’s mining companies already operating there should be able to buy up the rest of Afghanistan’s rare minerals.
Most of the Republicans just elected to Congress do not believe what their scientists tell them about man-made climate change. America’s politicians are mostly lawyers — not engineers or scientists like ours — so they’ll just say crazy things about science and nobody calls them on it. It’s good. It means they will not support any bill to spur clean energy innovation, which is central to our next five-year plan. And this ensures that our efforts to dominate the wind, solar, nuclear and electric car industries will not be challenged by America.
Finally, record numbers of U.S. high school students are now studying Chinese, which should guarantee us a steady supply of cheap labor that speaks our language here, as we use our $2.3 trillion in reserves to quietly buy up U.S. factories. In sum, things are going well for China in America.
Thank goodness the Americans can’t read our diplomatic cables.
Embassy Washington.
Here's the News. All the news worth reading. (To me anyway) Note that this is a news clippings blog. Articles (mainly from Straits Times) are NOT written by me. Due to spam comments, comments are now moderated. Please read "This Blog" and "Before you comment".
Thursday, December 2, 2010
Coal state's dark reckoning
Dec 2, 2010
Three years after the United States fell into its worst recession since World War II, many workers and families are still struggling with the fallout. In a three-part series, The Straits Times' US Bureau examines how the economic anxieties have affected ordinary Americans and the way they vote. In Part 2, we look at the perfect storm of economic challenges that is prompting a coal mining state to ask tough questions about its allegiances.
By Chua Chin Hon, US Bureau Chief in Washington
SYLVESTER (WEST VIRGINIA): When Mr Christopher Rusztowicz received his first pay cheque as a coal miner three weeks ago, he had little to celebrate.
After paying off the US$500 (S$657) he owed a supermarket and an electrical appliance store, he had US$190 left from the 45 tortuous hours he spent working each week in an underground mine here in southern West Virginia. To make ends meet, he took on a second job as a security guard that paid US$8 an hour.
Still, the 40-year-old considered his current situation an improvement over the low points in his life. For years, he was periodically homeless and lived out of a van while flitting from one temporary job to another.
At one point, he even had to sell his own blood plasma in order to pay for the medical bills of his cat - his one constant companion over the years.
When asked if he blamed anyone, Mr Rusztowicz said matter-of-factly that he felt 'sold out' by his government. If he had his way, he added, he would close the country's borders and ban foreign imports so that manufacturing jobs could thrive again in the US.
'Trade deals like Nafta (the North American Free Trade Agreement) completely changed the way I looked at the government,' he told The Straits Times over brunch at a local diner, where he owed US$300 in unpaid bills.
'The government should have found ways to keep the jobs here instead of shipping them overseas. The whole idea of 'government of the people, by the people, for the people' went right out of the window when they signed those trade deals.'
Such sentiments are not uncommon in heartland America, where workers have been squeezed not only by the recent recession but also by the decades-long decline of traditional manufacturing and industrial activity.
But in predominantly blue-collar West Virginia, struggling Americans like Mr Rusztowicz are not the only ones upset about the economy.
Well-off retirees, small business owners, conservative activists and the coal industry have found common cause in their opposition to a range of economic policies - which they believe are hurting the recovery and the country's long-term interests.
Deep differences
Comfortably retired from a long career with the government and the energy sector, Mrs Dee Armstrong could have spent the past 18 months travelling or relaxing at her two-storey log house built in the secluded woods of eastern West Virginia.
Instead, the 61-year-old threw herself into politics for the first time in her life, playing a leading role in the grassroots Tea Party movement which sprang from public anger over the economy.
Like many in the movement, she got involved not because she had lost her job or was struggling to make ends meet. Rather, she joined because she felt compelled to do something about the barrage of expensive economic policies that the Obama administration was pushing through.
By spending trillions of dollars to stimulate the economy, bail out Wall Street and rescue reckless home owners, the government was not only abandoning the free-market principles that built America, but also pushing the country towards insolvency and economic ruin, she argued.
In her view, President Barack Obama made matters worse when he signed into law earlier this year a trillion-dollar health-care overhaul that would further entrench the culture of welfarism at the heart of the economic malaise in West Virginia and the US.
'This is a free country, not a free ticket,' said an unapologetic Mrs Armstrong, who had previously worked for the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Department of Homeland Security. 'The 'entitlement majority' wants handouts, welfare, and health benefits when they don't contribute to any health systems or insurance. And guess who the government gets the money from? Me!'
Business owners like Mrs Aimee Peters, who runs a pizza restaurant in Martinsburg, West Virginia, also expressed concerns that the health-care changes would add further uncertainty to her business in an already uncertain economic climate.
The anger among conservatives like Mrs Armstrong stems from sharp philosophical differences with Mr Obama's Democratic Party on the appropriate economic role of the government. But it is by no means the only economic debate that is shaking up politics here.
There has been much anxiety in West Virginia of late - over the Obama administration's push for climate change legislation, and tighter regulation of a destructive coal mining technique known as 'mountain top removal', where explosives are used to blast off the top of mountains so miners can get to the coal seams.
To some, these are long overdue steps towards a clean energy future. But to many West Virginians, these moves are tantamount to open warfare on their economic lifeline - waged by the party in control of the state for the last 80 years or so, no less.
'When (Mr Obama) attacked coal, he attacked West Virginia,' said Mrs Kandi Montini, 43, a database administrator.
It is no surprise then that the coal industry poured millions of dollars - much of it going to the opposition Republicans - into influencing the outcome of the recent mid-term election.
Perfect storm
To outsiders, West Virginia is something of a political puzzle. Its predominantly white working-class population is socially conservative, but has voted mostly for the left-leaning Democratic Party since the Great Depression.
Its economy is one of the worst performing in the country, yet voters keep rewarding their elected officials - most of them Democrats - with long tenures in state and national-level offices.
For decades, West Virginia's internal political logic has seemed impervious to national trends.
But some observers believe that the perfect storm of economic anxieties that has been buffeting the rich, the poor, the business community and the coal industry alike is helping to forment a major political shake-up in this traditionally Democratic state.
'This is the beginning of an ideological tsunami,' said Mr Lance Schultz, a leading Tea Party activist based in Charleston, West Virginia's capital city.
While analysts are generally sceptical of such sweeping claims, they acknowledge that the results from last month's mid-term legislative elections point to a tough political environment ahead for Mr Obama's party.
Though the Democrats retained their overall dominance in West Virginia, the party lost a seat in the US House of Representatives which it had controlled for over four decades. The Republicans also picked up six state-level legislative seats, and gave many Democratic candidates a serious run for their money.
Popular Democratic governor Joe Manchin, for instance, was forced to tack to the right of the political spectrum on a range of issues before winning a hard-fought race for the US Senate. To fight off criticisms that he would be a 'rubber stamp' for Mr Obama, the candidate went as far as to shoot a real bullet through a proposed climate change Bill - to show he was serious about protecting West Virginia's economic interests.
Mr Schultz believes that more Democratic office holders in West Virginia would have been kicked out if he and the other Tea Party activists had reached out to more voters - something he promises to fix by the next election in 2012.
That, however, would be no easy task. For one thing, many of the coal and rural communities are in remote locations which do not even have cellphone signals. Many miners are also disinterested in politics, given the long, isolating hours they work underground.
Most importantly perhaps, many families here are dependent on state-funded welfare programmes as well as government-related projects that generate jobs in their area. Both could face severe cutbacks if the Republicans seize control.
But Ms Cindy Frich, a Republican newcomer who narrowly lost her race for a state legislative seat last month, said she encountered many voters who had begun to rethink these political sacred cows.
She added: 'We've always struggled economically in West Virginia and a lot of people are on welfare and transfer payments. You would think that people like that would be more for government health care, but they weren't.
'Many of them just wanted to stop what's going on in Washington, even if it meant that their vote would cut their benefits. It's just been too overwhelming.'
Dec 2, 2010
All fired up over 'War on Coal'
Govt's green policies seen as threat to jobs
BECKLEY (WEST VIRGINIA): Historically poor, residents in this isolated but coal-rich state have long been the subject of ridicule and cruel stereotyping.
What riled many people here in the past two years, however, was not some cheeky new insult about their rural lifestyles or fondness for guns.
Instead, it was something that cut deeply in these tough economic times: a so-called 'War on Coal' allegedly waged by the Obama administration against the backbone industry of West Virginia.
For many West Virginians, that adds insult to injury and has prompted some to begin questioning their political loyalties.
A billboard on the highway leading to the city of Beckley, a major hub in the southern coal fields, summed up West Virginia's mood best: 'Don't let EPA bureaucrats take away our coal jobs.'
Since President Barack Obama took office, the EPA, or the Environmental Protection Agency, has made several regulatory decisions that raised alarm bells in the coal industry.
For one thing, it practically froze all applications for mining permits involving the controversial technique of 'mountain top removal' - using explosives to remove the tops of mountains and thus exposing coal seams.
Even permits that had been granted previously - including one given the green light in 2007 for a massive 920ha coal strip mine in southern Logan county - were sent back for additional reviews on concerns that the operations would damage the region's wildlife and water quality.
Conservative activists like Mr Lance Schultz said such decisions were tantamount to a violation of the sanctity of contracts and an unacceptable intrusion into the rights that states like West Virginia enjoyed. 'West Virginia is ground zero of the war on freedom and our right to work,' he added.
The furore over the EPA's actions even prompted then Governor Joe Manchin, a Democrat, to file a lawsuit against the Obama administration's policies on mountain-top coal mining.
Days after he filed the lawsuit in October, Mr Manchin also starred in a controversial political advertisement where he literally shot down - using a rifle fitted with a scope, no less - a proposed climate change Bill widely opposed in West Virginia. Weeks later, the governor succeeded in his campaign to become the new junior senator from West Virginia.
Theatrics aside, the importance of coal to West Virginia's economy is plain to see. According to a recent joint study by the Marshall University and West Virginia University, the coal industry generated nearly US$20 billion (S$26.4 billion) in direct and indirect economic activity in West Virginia in 2008.
That same year, the industry employed 43,800 people either directly in mining companies or indirectly via retail and transportation jobs. The coal companies also paid about US$676.25 million in state and local taxes, the report added.
It said in its conclusion: 'Probably there is not another industry more vital to West Virginia's economy than coal... the loss of coal production or even a substantial reduction in its use would worsen an already bad situation, particularly in those areas which are most in need of jobs and income.'
Mr Obama, who is already under intense pressure over the weak economy and anaemic job creation, is not unaware of the stakes involved. As he told residents in the neighbouring state of Virginia in September, his goal was not to halt the use of coal, but to push the industry towards a 'cleaner' future.
He added: 'If we have regulations that provide incentives for coal companies to burn coal cleanly and mine coal cleanly, they'll adapt and they'll start using new technologies, and that will create a more future-oriented growth industry.
'If we're not the ones who get there first... then (China and India) are the ones who are going to get the jobs of the future. I want us to have those jobs right here in the United States.'
His message, however, had been largely lost on unconvinced West Virginians. Asked for her views on the Obama administration's plans to create green jobs, Ms Kandi Montini, a database administrator, said dismissively: 'I think that's just a lot of bunk.'
CHUA CHIN HON
Three years after the United States fell into its worst recession since World War II, many workers and families are still struggling with the fallout. In a three-part series, The Straits Times' US Bureau examines how the economic anxieties have affected ordinary Americans and the way they vote. In Part 2, we look at the perfect storm of economic challenges that is prompting a coal mining state to ask tough questions about its allegiances.
By Chua Chin Hon, US Bureau Chief in Washington
SYLVESTER (WEST VIRGINIA): When Mr Christopher Rusztowicz received his first pay cheque as a coal miner three weeks ago, he had little to celebrate.
After paying off the US$500 (S$657) he owed a supermarket and an electrical appliance store, he had US$190 left from the 45 tortuous hours he spent working each week in an underground mine here in southern West Virginia. To make ends meet, he took on a second job as a security guard that paid US$8 an hour.
Still, the 40-year-old considered his current situation an improvement over the low points in his life. For years, he was periodically homeless and lived out of a van while flitting from one temporary job to another.
At one point, he even had to sell his own blood plasma in order to pay for the medical bills of his cat - his one constant companion over the years.
When asked if he blamed anyone, Mr Rusztowicz said matter-of-factly that he felt 'sold out' by his government. If he had his way, he added, he would close the country's borders and ban foreign imports so that manufacturing jobs could thrive again in the US.
'Trade deals like Nafta (the North American Free Trade Agreement) completely changed the way I looked at the government,' he told The Straits Times over brunch at a local diner, where he owed US$300 in unpaid bills.
'The government should have found ways to keep the jobs here instead of shipping them overseas. The whole idea of 'government of the people, by the people, for the people' went right out of the window when they signed those trade deals.'
Such sentiments are not uncommon in heartland America, where workers have been squeezed not only by the recent recession but also by the decades-long decline of traditional manufacturing and industrial activity.
But in predominantly blue-collar West Virginia, struggling Americans like Mr Rusztowicz are not the only ones upset about the economy.
Well-off retirees, small business owners, conservative activists and the coal industry have found common cause in their opposition to a range of economic policies - which they believe are hurting the recovery and the country's long-term interests.
Deep differences
Comfortably retired from a long career with the government and the energy sector, Mrs Dee Armstrong could have spent the past 18 months travelling or relaxing at her two-storey log house built in the secluded woods of eastern West Virginia.
Instead, the 61-year-old threw herself into politics for the first time in her life, playing a leading role in the grassroots Tea Party movement which sprang from public anger over the economy.
Like many in the movement, she got involved not because she had lost her job or was struggling to make ends meet. Rather, she joined because she felt compelled to do something about the barrage of expensive economic policies that the Obama administration was pushing through.
By spending trillions of dollars to stimulate the economy, bail out Wall Street and rescue reckless home owners, the government was not only abandoning the free-market principles that built America, but also pushing the country towards insolvency and economic ruin, she argued.
In her view, President Barack Obama made matters worse when he signed into law earlier this year a trillion-dollar health-care overhaul that would further entrench the culture of welfarism at the heart of the economic malaise in West Virginia and the US.
'This is a free country, not a free ticket,' said an unapologetic Mrs Armstrong, who had previously worked for the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Department of Homeland Security. 'The 'entitlement majority' wants handouts, welfare, and health benefits when they don't contribute to any health systems or insurance. And guess who the government gets the money from? Me!'
Business owners like Mrs Aimee Peters, who runs a pizza restaurant in Martinsburg, West Virginia, also expressed concerns that the health-care changes would add further uncertainty to her business in an already uncertain economic climate.
The anger among conservatives like Mrs Armstrong stems from sharp philosophical differences with Mr Obama's Democratic Party on the appropriate economic role of the government. But it is by no means the only economic debate that is shaking up politics here.
There has been much anxiety in West Virginia of late - over the Obama administration's push for climate change legislation, and tighter regulation of a destructive coal mining technique known as 'mountain top removal', where explosives are used to blast off the top of mountains so miners can get to the coal seams.
To some, these are long overdue steps towards a clean energy future. But to many West Virginians, these moves are tantamount to open warfare on their economic lifeline - waged by the party in control of the state for the last 80 years or so, no less.
'When (Mr Obama) attacked coal, he attacked West Virginia,' said Mrs Kandi Montini, 43, a database administrator.
It is no surprise then that the coal industry poured millions of dollars - much of it going to the opposition Republicans - into influencing the outcome of the recent mid-term election.
Perfect storm
To outsiders, West Virginia is something of a political puzzle. Its predominantly white working-class population is socially conservative, but has voted mostly for the left-leaning Democratic Party since the Great Depression.
Its economy is one of the worst performing in the country, yet voters keep rewarding their elected officials - most of them Democrats - with long tenures in state and national-level offices.
For decades, West Virginia's internal political logic has seemed impervious to national trends.
But some observers believe that the perfect storm of economic anxieties that has been buffeting the rich, the poor, the business community and the coal industry alike is helping to forment a major political shake-up in this traditionally Democratic state.
'This is the beginning of an ideological tsunami,' said Mr Lance Schultz, a leading Tea Party activist based in Charleston, West Virginia's capital city.
While analysts are generally sceptical of such sweeping claims, they acknowledge that the results from last month's mid-term legislative elections point to a tough political environment ahead for Mr Obama's party.
Though the Democrats retained their overall dominance in West Virginia, the party lost a seat in the US House of Representatives which it had controlled for over four decades. The Republicans also picked up six state-level legislative seats, and gave many Democratic candidates a serious run for their money.
Popular Democratic governor Joe Manchin, for instance, was forced to tack to the right of the political spectrum on a range of issues before winning a hard-fought race for the US Senate. To fight off criticisms that he would be a 'rubber stamp' for Mr Obama, the candidate went as far as to shoot a real bullet through a proposed climate change Bill - to show he was serious about protecting West Virginia's economic interests.
Mr Schultz believes that more Democratic office holders in West Virginia would have been kicked out if he and the other Tea Party activists had reached out to more voters - something he promises to fix by the next election in 2012.
That, however, would be no easy task. For one thing, many of the coal and rural communities are in remote locations which do not even have cellphone signals. Many miners are also disinterested in politics, given the long, isolating hours they work underground.
Most importantly perhaps, many families here are dependent on state-funded welfare programmes as well as government-related projects that generate jobs in their area. Both could face severe cutbacks if the Republicans seize control.
But Ms Cindy Frich, a Republican newcomer who narrowly lost her race for a state legislative seat last month, said she encountered many voters who had begun to rethink these political sacred cows.
She added: 'We've always struggled economically in West Virginia and a lot of people are on welfare and transfer payments. You would think that people like that would be more for government health care, but they weren't.
'Many of them just wanted to stop what's going on in Washington, even if it meant that their vote would cut their benefits. It's just been too overwhelming.'
Dec 2, 2010
All fired up over 'War on Coal'
Govt's green policies seen as threat to jobs
BECKLEY (WEST VIRGINIA): Historically poor, residents in this isolated but coal-rich state have long been the subject of ridicule and cruel stereotyping.
What riled many people here in the past two years, however, was not some cheeky new insult about their rural lifestyles or fondness for guns.
Instead, it was something that cut deeply in these tough economic times: a so-called 'War on Coal' allegedly waged by the Obama administration against the backbone industry of West Virginia.
For many West Virginians, that adds insult to injury and has prompted some to begin questioning their political loyalties.
A billboard on the highway leading to the city of Beckley, a major hub in the southern coal fields, summed up West Virginia's mood best: 'Don't let EPA bureaucrats take away our coal jobs.'
Since President Barack Obama took office, the EPA, or the Environmental Protection Agency, has made several regulatory decisions that raised alarm bells in the coal industry.
For one thing, it practically froze all applications for mining permits involving the controversial technique of 'mountain top removal' - using explosives to remove the tops of mountains and thus exposing coal seams.
Even permits that had been granted previously - including one given the green light in 2007 for a massive 920ha coal strip mine in southern Logan county - were sent back for additional reviews on concerns that the operations would damage the region's wildlife and water quality.
Conservative activists like Mr Lance Schultz said such decisions were tantamount to a violation of the sanctity of contracts and an unacceptable intrusion into the rights that states like West Virginia enjoyed. 'West Virginia is ground zero of the war on freedom and our right to work,' he added.
The furore over the EPA's actions even prompted then Governor Joe Manchin, a Democrat, to file a lawsuit against the Obama administration's policies on mountain-top coal mining.
Days after he filed the lawsuit in October, Mr Manchin also starred in a controversial political advertisement where he literally shot down - using a rifle fitted with a scope, no less - a proposed climate change Bill widely opposed in West Virginia. Weeks later, the governor succeeded in his campaign to become the new junior senator from West Virginia.
Theatrics aside, the importance of coal to West Virginia's economy is plain to see. According to a recent joint study by the Marshall University and West Virginia University, the coal industry generated nearly US$20 billion (S$26.4 billion) in direct and indirect economic activity in West Virginia in 2008.
That same year, the industry employed 43,800 people either directly in mining companies or indirectly via retail and transportation jobs. The coal companies also paid about US$676.25 million in state and local taxes, the report added.
It said in its conclusion: 'Probably there is not another industry more vital to West Virginia's economy than coal... the loss of coal production or even a substantial reduction in its use would worsen an already bad situation, particularly in those areas which are most in need of jobs and income.'
Mr Obama, who is already under intense pressure over the weak economy and anaemic job creation, is not unaware of the stakes involved. As he told residents in the neighbouring state of Virginia in September, his goal was not to halt the use of coal, but to push the industry towards a 'cleaner' future.
He added: 'If we have regulations that provide incentives for coal companies to burn coal cleanly and mine coal cleanly, they'll adapt and they'll start using new technologies, and that will create a more future-oriented growth industry.
'If we're not the ones who get there first... then (China and India) are the ones who are going to get the jobs of the future. I want us to have those jobs right here in the United States.'
His message, however, had been largely lost on unconvinced West Virginians. Asked for her views on the Obama administration's plans to create green jobs, Ms Kandi Montini, a database administrator, said dismissively: 'I think that's just a lot of bunk.'
CHUA CHIN HON
Weak economy despite wealth of resources
ECONOMY
- West Virginia's economy is among the weakest in the United States, ranking 40th in a list of 50 states despite its wealth of natural resources like coal and timber. It is the second-largest coal producer in the US, behind the state of Wyoming.
- Its unemployment rate in October was 9.3 per cent, slightly lower than the national average of 9.6 per cent. But job figures do not tell the full story about West Virginia's economy, which suffers mainly from a lack of diversity and entrepreneurship.
- Many families live from pay cheque to pay cheque and rely heavily on government welfare programmes. This is borne out by statistics showing West Virginia's median household income to be the lowest in the country.
POLITICS
- The Democratic Party has largely dominated politics in West Virginia since the Great Depression, thanks to the powerful influence of the coal mining unions. Democrats currently control most of the state-level offices, and a majority of the national-level legislative seats in the House of Representatives and Senate.
- Republicans, however, have become much more competitive in last month's election, aided by the rise of the Tea Party, a grassroots conservative movement. West Virginian voters have also sided with Republican presidential candidates since 2000, a trend that is likely to continue in 2012.
- While registered Democrats here outnumber their Republican counterparts by nearly two to one, most Democrats in West Virginia are much more conservative than their counterparts in the coastal areas. This factor, combined with the state's dependence on coal, explains why climate change legislation and the government's recent economic policies have been unpopular.
Steel town now an economic ghost town
Dec 1, 2010
Three years after the United States fell into the worst recession since World War II, many workers and families are still struggling with the fallout. In a three-part series, The Straits Times US Bureau examines how the economic anxieties have affected ordinary Americans and the way they vote. In Part 1, we look at why some residents of a declining steel town are rebelling against their political roots.
By Tracy Quek
BRADDOCK (PENNSYLVANIA): Since she moved here 14 years ago, Mrs Carmella Mullen has watched the economic lifeblood drain out of this historic steel-making town with a mixture of disappointment and despair.
But when the town's hospital - and last remaining economic lifeline - announced it was closing in October last year, her frustration boiled over.
The 61-year-old blamed the local Democratic officials for failing to prevent the closure of the town's biggest employer.
Not just jobs were lost. Gone with the hospital were the town's only restaurant - the hospital cafeteria - and its only ATM.
Months later, Mrs Mullen quit a leadership position she had held since 2006 in the local Democratic Party committee.
She did not stop there. When the midterm legislative polls opened on Nov 2, she further rebelled against the party she had actively supported for most of her life by voting for the Republican candidate in the Pennsylvania governor race.
'The hospital was just the last straw,' said Mrs Mullen, a housewife. 'I'm voting for people and principles and I refuse to reward someone for making this town worse off.'
Her story is one that has echoes around the country. Similar feelings of disillusionment, particularly over the economy, prompted many Americans to sour on the promise of change made by President Barack Obama, and turned on his Democratic Party at the recent midterm elections.
Even a staunchly Democratic town like Braddock, with its working-class population and strong union history, was not immune to the voter revolt. Across the nation, whether in towns like this one - once home to the standard-bearers of the American steel industry - or in Michigan, the state where the modern auto industry was born, voters made plain that they want more attention - and results - on the economic front.
Downward spiral
ONCE a thriving industrial town with some 21,000 inhabitants, Braddock was hit hard by the collapse of the American steel industry in the 1980s.
Steel mills which once employed more than 10,000 workers drastically cut production. People and businesses left for opportunities elsewhere.
Today, Braddock is a 'distressed municipality' and home to less than 3,000 people - an 86 per cent drop from its peak population in the 1940s.
Jobs are scarce. The local unemployment rate is above 30 per cent, three times the national level.
The average household income here is about US$20,000 (S$26,500) a year, hovering below the official poverty line of US$22,050 for a family of four. Many cannot afford to buy their own homes.
Residents like Mr Mike Nash and his wife Jennifer consider themselves the working poor.
'I work my ass off for very little, and I stretch it for as far as I can. Just doing what I have to do to survive, and there ain't much,' said Mr Nash, a 35-year-old truck driver and father of four teenagers.
Like many here, Mr Nash has long struggled to imagine anything other than a bleak future for his hometown after decades of decline. But three years ago, a junior senator from Illinois running for president stirred up feelings of hope and renewal.
A registered Republican, Mr Nash said he took a chance and voted for Mr Obama in 2008. But barely a year later, he regretted his decision.
'I realised everything he said he was going to do - the bailouts, the economic stimulus - was a mistake,' he told The Straits Times.
Early in his presidency, Mr Obama pushed through a US$814 billion stimulus package aimed at creating jobs and restoring economic growth at a time when the country was at the precipice of what has been described as the worst downturn since the Great Depression. While recent figures appear to suggest that the stimulus did help, in towns like Braddock, residents feel there has been little appreciable impact.
'I mean, where are the jobs, darn it? I don't see them in the construction sites I'm on,' said Mr Nash.
In truth, Braddock did receive some stimulus funds - US$250,000 last year to upgrade its sewer system and an additional US$30,000 for a community programme aimed at providing employment for youth in the area, Braddock Mayor John Fetterman told CNN in January.
But a walk around town makes it easy to see why many might think that Braddock has not benefited at all.
Braddock Avenue, the town's once-bustling main commercial street, is now a forlorn stretch of boarded-up store fronts and crumbling buildings. There remain only a handful of local businesses, including two small grocers, an optician and a couple of used-furniture shops.
Once-handsome brick houses now stand vacant, their front yards overgrown with weeds. Drug abuse and crime are rampant enough to make locals nervous about venturing outside after dark.
Similar scenes can be found in many Rust Belt towns across Pennsylvania.
It was no surprise, then, that in election races in the state and across the nation, Democrats floundered in their attempts to convince voters that the economic stimulus has made a positive impact. Republican rhetoric on fiscal responsibility, on the other hand, resonated with families who had instinctively tightened their belts to weather the recession.
Americans expecting the new administration's priorities to match their own concerns on the economy grew increasingly frustrated as they watched the White House squander legislative opportunities to tackle those problems head-on.
The stinging rebuke they delivered on Nov 2 was the result.
Shifting allegiances
PENNSYLVANIA reflects the national mood. The state, which has backed every Democratic presidential candidate since 1992, including Mr Obama two years ago, this time handed Republicans their biggest state-wide electoral victory since 1994.
Pennsylvania Republicans won a hotly contested Senate race, picked up five congressional seats, and recaptured the governorship and the state House of Representatives from the Democrats.
What was more significant was that the senator and governor-elects both overcame the Democratic Party's big advantage in registered voters: they outnumber Republicans by 1.2 million.
Mrs Mullen, the former Democratic Party official, noted: 'No Republican politician can win in Pennsylvania unless people who are registered Democrat or Independent vote for them.'
But do the results of the Nov 2 election represent the beginnings of a permanent shift in voter loyalty away from the Democrats? Or is this merely a hiccup that Mr Obama and his party can brush aside once stronger job creation and economic recovery resume?
It is too early to make predictions for the next presidential election in 2012. But if the rumblings afoot in towns like Braddock are any indication, the Democrats cannot afford to take any future support for granted.
'There are some who will always vote Democratic because that is what their families have done for generations,' said Mrs Mullen. 'But more and more, people are going to be thinking for themselves.'
The devastating loss of the 123-bed Braddock Hospital, which locals considered the heart of the town, was a wake-up call, many reckoned. Even those who come from a long line of die-hard Democratic voters are re-examining their convictions.
Mr Mike Yezovich grew up hearing kitchen table talk about the party that shaped his political loyalties as a young man.
'People would say Democrats are for the working class, Republicans are for the rich. I guess in my youth, I believed what my parents and grandparents believed,' said the 54-year-old cemetery caretaker.
But his convictions changed over time and he no longer votes a straight Democratic ticket, preferring to support pro-life advocates and political candidates he thinks are best suited for the job.
'My grandmother would roll over in her grave if she found out I was voting Republican,' chuckled the father of 12. But the Democratic Party is not what it once was, he added solemnly.
'It just feels like it's out of touch with the ordinary American, especially those who are struggling like us,' said Mr Yezovich, who mows lawns to supplement his income of US$43,000 a year.
His wife Danette, 50, recently found a job in a day-care centre because the family could no longer live on his pay alone. The couple and six of their children share a three-bedroom apartment they rent for US$336 a month. Mr Yezovich reckons he will never be able to own a home.
'I know it's not just a simple thing for one party to come in and change anything. But you just wonder sometimes, there are a lot of promises, but you don't see it on the ground,' he said.
Asked if there was a possibility of Braddock seeing better days, Mr Yezovich said he continues to hope against hope.
But, he admitted: 'When you see things so bad for so long, you lose your faith in a lot of what's told to you. You don't know what to believe any more.'
tracyq@sph.com.sg
Three years after the United States fell into the worst recession since World War II, many workers and families are still struggling with the fallout. In a three-part series, The Straits Times US Bureau examines how the economic anxieties have affected ordinary Americans and the way they vote. In Part 1, we look at why some residents of a declining steel town are rebelling against their political roots.
By Tracy Quek
BRADDOCK (PENNSYLVANIA): Since she moved here 14 years ago, Mrs Carmella Mullen has watched the economic lifeblood drain out of this historic steel-making town with a mixture of disappointment and despair.
But when the town's hospital - and last remaining economic lifeline - announced it was closing in October last year, her frustration boiled over.
The 61-year-old blamed the local Democratic officials for failing to prevent the closure of the town's biggest employer.
Not just jobs were lost. Gone with the hospital were the town's only restaurant - the hospital cafeteria - and its only ATM.
Months later, Mrs Mullen quit a leadership position she had held since 2006 in the local Democratic Party committee.
She did not stop there. When the midterm legislative polls opened on Nov 2, she further rebelled against the party she had actively supported for most of her life by voting for the Republican candidate in the Pennsylvania governor race.
'The hospital was just the last straw,' said Mrs Mullen, a housewife. 'I'm voting for people and principles and I refuse to reward someone for making this town worse off.'
Her story is one that has echoes around the country. Similar feelings of disillusionment, particularly over the economy, prompted many Americans to sour on the promise of change made by President Barack Obama, and turned on his Democratic Party at the recent midterm elections.
Even a staunchly Democratic town like Braddock, with its working-class population and strong union history, was not immune to the voter revolt. Across the nation, whether in towns like this one - once home to the standard-bearers of the American steel industry - or in Michigan, the state where the modern auto industry was born, voters made plain that they want more attention - and results - on the economic front.
Downward spiral
ONCE a thriving industrial town with some 21,000 inhabitants, Braddock was hit hard by the collapse of the American steel industry in the 1980s.
Steel mills which once employed more than 10,000 workers drastically cut production. People and businesses left for opportunities elsewhere.
Today, Braddock is a 'distressed municipality' and home to less than 3,000 people - an 86 per cent drop from its peak population in the 1940s.
Jobs are scarce. The local unemployment rate is above 30 per cent, three times the national level.
The average household income here is about US$20,000 (S$26,500) a year, hovering below the official poverty line of US$22,050 for a family of four. Many cannot afford to buy their own homes.
Residents like Mr Mike Nash and his wife Jennifer consider themselves the working poor.
'I work my ass off for very little, and I stretch it for as far as I can. Just doing what I have to do to survive, and there ain't much,' said Mr Nash, a 35-year-old truck driver and father of four teenagers.
Like many here, Mr Nash has long struggled to imagine anything other than a bleak future for his hometown after decades of decline. But three years ago, a junior senator from Illinois running for president stirred up feelings of hope and renewal.
A registered Republican, Mr Nash said he took a chance and voted for Mr Obama in 2008. But barely a year later, he regretted his decision.
'I realised everything he said he was going to do - the bailouts, the economic stimulus - was a mistake,' he told The Straits Times.
Early in his presidency, Mr Obama pushed through a US$814 billion stimulus package aimed at creating jobs and restoring economic growth at a time when the country was at the precipice of what has been described as the worst downturn since the Great Depression. While recent figures appear to suggest that the stimulus did help, in towns like Braddock, residents feel there has been little appreciable impact.
'I mean, where are the jobs, darn it? I don't see them in the construction sites I'm on,' said Mr Nash.
In truth, Braddock did receive some stimulus funds - US$250,000 last year to upgrade its sewer system and an additional US$30,000 for a community programme aimed at providing employment for youth in the area, Braddock Mayor John Fetterman told CNN in January.
But a walk around town makes it easy to see why many might think that Braddock has not benefited at all.
Braddock Avenue, the town's once-bustling main commercial street, is now a forlorn stretch of boarded-up store fronts and crumbling buildings. There remain only a handful of local businesses, including two small grocers, an optician and a couple of used-furniture shops.
Once-handsome brick houses now stand vacant, their front yards overgrown with weeds. Drug abuse and crime are rampant enough to make locals nervous about venturing outside after dark.
Similar scenes can be found in many Rust Belt towns across Pennsylvania.
It was no surprise, then, that in election races in the state and across the nation, Democrats floundered in their attempts to convince voters that the economic stimulus has made a positive impact. Republican rhetoric on fiscal responsibility, on the other hand, resonated with families who had instinctively tightened their belts to weather the recession.
Americans expecting the new administration's priorities to match their own concerns on the economy grew increasingly frustrated as they watched the White House squander legislative opportunities to tackle those problems head-on.
The stinging rebuke they delivered on Nov 2 was the result.
Shifting allegiances
PENNSYLVANIA reflects the national mood. The state, which has backed every Democratic presidential candidate since 1992, including Mr Obama two years ago, this time handed Republicans their biggest state-wide electoral victory since 1994.
Pennsylvania Republicans won a hotly contested Senate race, picked up five congressional seats, and recaptured the governorship and the state House of Representatives from the Democrats.
What was more significant was that the senator and governor-elects both overcame the Democratic Party's big advantage in registered voters: they outnumber Republicans by 1.2 million.
Mrs Mullen, the former Democratic Party official, noted: 'No Republican politician can win in Pennsylvania unless people who are registered Democrat or Independent vote for them.'
But do the results of the Nov 2 election represent the beginnings of a permanent shift in voter loyalty away from the Democrats? Or is this merely a hiccup that Mr Obama and his party can brush aside once stronger job creation and economic recovery resume?
It is too early to make predictions for the next presidential election in 2012. But if the rumblings afoot in towns like Braddock are any indication, the Democrats cannot afford to take any future support for granted.
'There are some who will always vote Democratic because that is what their families have done for generations,' said Mrs Mullen. 'But more and more, people are going to be thinking for themselves.'
The devastating loss of the 123-bed Braddock Hospital, which locals considered the heart of the town, was a wake-up call, many reckoned. Even those who come from a long line of die-hard Democratic voters are re-examining their convictions.
Mr Mike Yezovich grew up hearing kitchen table talk about the party that shaped his political loyalties as a young man.
'People would say Democrats are for the working class, Republicans are for the rich. I guess in my youth, I believed what my parents and grandparents believed,' said the 54-year-old cemetery caretaker.
But his convictions changed over time and he no longer votes a straight Democratic ticket, preferring to support pro-life advocates and political candidates he thinks are best suited for the job.
'My grandmother would roll over in her grave if she found out I was voting Republican,' chuckled the father of 12. But the Democratic Party is not what it once was, he added solemnly.
'It just feels like it's out of touch with the ordinary American, especially those who are struggling like us,' said Mr Yezovich, who mows lawns to supplement his income of US$43,000 a year.
His wife Danette, 50, recently found a job in a day-care centre because the family could no longer live on his pay alone. The couple and six of their children share a three-bedroom apartment they rent for US$336 a month. Mr Yezovich reckons he will never be able to own a home.
'I know it's not just a simple thing for one party to come in and change anything. But you just wonder sometimes, there are a lot of promises, but you don't see it on the ground,' he said.
Asked if there was a possibility of Braddock seeing better days, Mr Yezovich said he continues to hope against hope.
But, he admitted: 'When you see things so bad for so long, you lose your faith in a lot of what's told to you. You don't know what to believe any more.'
tracyq@sph.com.sg
US embassy cables: Former Singapore PM on 'psychopathic' North Koreans
Thursday, 04 June 2009, 09:08
S E C R E T SINGAPORE 000529
EO 12958 DECL: 06/04/2029
TAGS OVIP">OVIP (STEINBERG, JAMES B.), PREL, MNUC, ECON, SN, CH, KN
SUBJECT: DEPUTY SECRETARY STEINBERG'S MAY 30, 2009
CONVERSATION WITH SINGAPORE MINISTER MENTOR LEE KUAN YEW
Classified By: Charge d'Affaires Daniel L. Shields. Reason 1.4 (b) and (d).
Summary
1. Former prime minister of Singapore Lee Kuan Yew says China does not want North Korea to have nuclear weapons or to collapse, but would prefer the former. He doesn't believe Pyongyang will give up nuclear weapons as a form of defence and describes North Koreans as "psychopathic", but holds out hope for change under a new leader. Key passage highlighted in yellow.
1. (SBU) May 30, 2009; 6:30 p.m.; The Presidential Palace; Singapore.
2. (SBU) Participants: United States
-------------
The Deputy Secretary Glyn T. Davies, EAP
Acting Assistant Secretary Daniel L. Shields, CDA (Notetaker)
SINGAPORE
---------
Minister Mentor (MM) Lee Kuan Yew
Chee Hong Tat, Principal Private Secretary to MM
Cheryl Lee, Country Officer, Americas Directorate, MFA
3. (S) SUMMARY: Deputy Secretary Steinberg used his meeting with Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew to stress the importance of Chinese cooperation in addressing the North Korea nuclear issue and to elicit MM Lee's views on China and North Korea. MM Lee said the Chinese do not want North Korea to have nuclear weapons and do not want North Korea to collapse. If China has to choose, Beijing sees a North Korea with nuclear weapons as less bad than a North Korea that has collapsed. MM Lee asked Deputy Chief of the People's Liberation Army (PLA) General Staff Ma Xiaotian what China can do about North Korea. General Ma's answer was that "they can survive on their own." The Deputy Secretary noted that the DPRK could have a fair and attractive deal if it would change its approach. If not, North Korea faces a change of course by the United States, the ROK and Japan. MM Lee said he believes Japan may well "go nuclear." MM Lee also offered views on the Chinese economy, Taiwan, Chinese leaders, and U.S.-China relations. End Summary.
China and North Korea
---------------------
4. (S) Deputy Secretary Steinberg met with Singapore Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew on May 30 on the margins of the Shangri-La Dialogue, the annual international security forum held in Singapore. The Deputy Secretary used the meeting with MM Lee to stress the importance of Chinese cooperation in addressing the North Korea nuclear issue and to elicit MM Lee's views on China and North Korea. MM Lee said the Chinese do not want North Korea to have nuclear weapons. At the same time, the Chinese do not want North Korea, which China sees as a buffer state, to collapse. The ROK would take over in the North and China would face a U.S. presence at its border. If China has to choose, Beijing sees a North Korea with nuclear weapons as less bad for China than a North Korea that has collapsed, he stated.
5. (S) MM Lee said he asked Deputy Chief of the People's Liberation Army (PLA) General Staff Ma Xiaotian what China can do about North Korea. General Ma's Delphic answer was that "they can survive on their own." MM Lee said he interpreted this as meaning that even if China cut off aid, the DPRK leadership would survive. This is a leadership that has already taken actions like killing ROK Cabinet Members in Burma and shooting down a KAL flight. If they lose power, they will end up facing justice at The Hague, like Milosevic. They have been so isolated for so long that they have no friends, not even Russia. They have not trusted China since the Chinese began cultivating ties with the ROK, given China's interest in attracting foreign investment, he said. The Deputy Secretary noted that the DPRK could have a fair and attractive deal if it would change its approach. If not, North Korea faces a change of course by the United States, the ROK and Japan. MM Lee expressed worry about the effect on Iran if the DPRK persists. MM Lee said he believes the DPRK can be contained and will not proliferate, but Iran has very high ambitions, ties to Shiite communities outside Iran, and oil wealth.
6. (S) The Deputy Secretary noted that North Korea's decisions will have an impact in Japan. MM Lee said he believes Japan may well "go nuclear." The Chinese must have factored this into their calculations and concluded that the prospect of Japan with nuclear weapons is less bad than losing North Korea as a buffer state. The Chinese take a long-term view and must think that within a few years the DPRK's current leadership will be gone and there will be new leadership, with new thinking. But there will still be a North Korea, he said.
7. (S) MM Lee said he wishes the USG well in its efforts on North Korea, but he would be surprised if the North Koreans agree to give up nuclear weapons. They might give up a first-strike capacity, but they want nuclear weapons in case the USG decides to seek regime change. They are psychopathic types, with a "flabby old chap" for a leader who prances around stadiums seeking adulation. MM Lee noted that he had learned from living through three and a half years of Japanese occupation in Singapore that people will obey authorities who can deny them food, clothing and medicine.
8. (S) MM Lee said the ROK, after seeing what had happened with German unification, does not want immediate unification with the DPRK. There is "nothing there" in the DPRK, other than a military organization. Kim Jong-Il has already had a stroke. It is just a matter of time before he has another stroke. The next leader may not have the gumption or the bile of his father or grandfather. He may not be prepared to see people die like flies. China is calculating all this. They have their best men on the job. They want to help the United States to advance common objectives. But they do not want the South to take over the North, MM Lee said.
Chinese Economy
---------------
9. (C) Regarding the Chinese economy, MM Lee said the global economic crisis has hit many countries, but the feel on the ground differs considerably from place to place. The Chinese economy is reportedly in the doldrums, but when MM Lee visited Jiangsu Province on May 24, his impression was one of continued prosperity. Shanghai has been harder hit, with container port traffic down 30-35 percent, similar to the situation in Singapore. There is no sign of deep unrest in China. The Chinese are very confident they will be able to sustain eight percent growth. The government is pumping resources into the economy, with a focus on developing Western China. Whether such policies can be sustained for three to four years is unclear, but China can certainly sustain these policies for at least a year, he said.
10. (C) MM Lee stated that in the absence of a social safety net in China, the Chinese savings rate is 55 percent, exceeding even Singapore's 50 percent level. Consumption accounts for only 35 percent of Chinese GDP, as opposed to 70 percent of U.S. GDP. The Chinese leadership may be loath to shift permanently to a more consumption-oriented economy, but the leadership will do so temporarily, if only to avoid unrest. 20 million people have moved back to the countryside because of economic dislocations. The government is providing microfinance to facilitate the transition. The pragmatists are in charge. There is nothing Communist about it. They just want to preserve one party rule. The Deputy Secretary expressed concern that current Chinese policies designed to counter the economic crisis could undermine reform. MM Lee said this cannot be helped. China wants to prevent riots like the ones that happened in Guangzhou in March when Hong Kong-connected enterprises suddenly shut down, he said.
Taiwan
------
11. (C) The Deputy Secretary asked MM Lee for his assessment of Taiwan. MM Lee said former President Chen Shui-bian had left Taiwan in a weak economic position, which had enabled President Ma Ying-Jeou to come to power with his pledge to strengthen the economy through means including expanding the three links with China. In Beijing, former President Jiang Zemin was wedded to his eight-point approach, but President Hu Jintao was more flexible. Jiang wanted to show he was a great man by solving the Taiwan issue in his lifetime, but Hu is more patient and does not have any fixed timeline. In Chinese domestic politics, Hu had wanted Vice Premier Li Keqiang from the Communist Youth League to emerge as his successor, not Vice President Xi Jinping, but Hu did his calculations and accepted Xi when it became clear that Xi had the necessary backing from the rest of the leadership. Similarly, on Taiwan, Hu will be pragmatic. It does not matter to Hu if it takes 10 years or 20 or 30. The key is building links with Taiwan. As in the case of Hong Kong, if necessary the tap could be turned off, he said.
12. (C) In this context, MM Lee said, Hu could live with Ma's positions on the '92 consensus and on not addressing the reunification issue during his term in office. What mattered to Hu was that Taiwan not seek independence. If that happened, China has 1,000 missiles and is building its capacity to hold the U.S. fleet at a distance. The implicit question for Taiwan's leaders is if that is what they want, MM Lee said.
13. (C) MM Lee stated that the alternative is Mainland investment in Taiwan stocks and property. The Mainland has already assured Hong Kong that it will help out economically. The Mainland has not said this to Taiwan, but the Mainland's Taiwan Affairs Director, Wang Yi, did urge Chinese companies to invest in Taiwan. In four years Taiwan's economy will pick up and Ma will win re-election. The DPP lacks strong potential candidates. Su Zhen-chang is promising, but seems unlikely to be able to win. Meanwhile, even the traditionally DPP-supporting farmers in Taiwan's South need China's market for vegetables and other products. Taiwan's continued participation in the World Health Assembly depends on Beijing. Beijing's calculation seems to be to prevent Taiwan independence in the near term, then bring Taiwan "back to China," even if it takes 40 or 50 years. MM Lee said he is looking forward to visiting Fujian Province, where preparations are underway for a new southern economic area linked with Taiwan.
Xi Jinping
----------
14. (C) The Deputy Secretary asked if in the future a leader like Xi Jinping would continue the policies on Taiwan followed by Hu Jintao. MM Lee responded affirmatively. Xi is a princeling who succeeded despite being rusticated. When the party needed his talents, Xi was brought in as Shanghai Party Secretary. Xi is seen as a Jiang Zemin protege, but in another three and a half years Jiang's influence will be gone. The focus now is on maintaining the system. There are no more strongmen like Deng Xiaoping. Jiang did not like Hu, but could not stop him, because Hu had the backing of the system and he did not make mistakes.
Wang Qishan
-----------
15. (C) MM Lee said Vice Premier Wang Qishan, whom the MM saw in connection with celebrations in May of the 15th anniversary of Singapore-China Suzhou Industrial Park, is an exceptional talent, very assured and efficient. Wang handled SARS superbly when he was in Hainan. He excelled in coordinating the Beijing Olympics. Li Keqiang may not get the Premiership and the Party is looking for a way to keep Wang on past his 65th birthday until he is 70. MM Lee said he had met first Wang back in the 1990s but had forgotten their meeting. This time when they met, Wang told Lee he had reviewed the records of all Lee's meeting with Chinese leaders going back to the days of Deng Xiaoping to see how Lee's thinking had developed. Wang told Lee he respects him as a consistent man.
China's Rise
------------
16. (C) MM Lee said China is following an approach consistent with ideas in the Chinese television series "The Rise of Great Powers." The mistake of Germany and Japan had been their effort to challenge the existing order. The Chinese are not stupid; they have avoided this mistake. China's economy has surpassed other countries, with the exceptions of Japan and the United States. Even with those two countries, the gap is closing, with China growing at seven-nine percent annually, versus two-three percent in the United States and Japan. Overall GDP, not GDP per capita, is what matters in terms of power. China has four times the population of the United States. China is active in Latin America, Africa, and in the Gulf. Within hours, everything that is discussed in ASEAN meetings is known in Beijing, given China's close ties with Laos, Cambodia, and Burma, he stated.
17. (C) MM Lee said China will not reach the American level in terms of military capabilities any time soon, but is rapidly developing asymmetrical means to deter U.S. military power. China understands that its growth depends on imports, including energy, raw materials, and food. This is why China is working with South Africa on the China-Africa Development Fund. China also needs open sea lanes. Beijing is worried about its dependence on the Strait of Malacca and is moving to ease the dependence by means like a pipeline through Burma.
Build Ties with Young Chinese
-----------------------------
18. (C) MM Lee said the best course for the United States on China is to build ties with China's young people. China's best and brightest want to study in the United States, with the UK as the next option, then Japan. While they are there, it is important that they be treated as equals, with the cultural support they may need as foreigners. Why not have International Military Education and Training (IMET) programs for China? Why not have Chinese cadets at West Point alongside Vietnamese cadets and Indian cadets? America's advantage is that it can make use of the talent of the entire world, as in Silicon Valley. China still tends to try to keep the foreigners in Beijing and Shanghai. MM Lee noted that his own experience as a student in the UK had left him with an enduring fondness for the UK. When he spent two months at Harvard in 1968, an American professor had invited him home for Thanksgiving. This was not the sort of thing that happened in the UK, and Lee had realized he was dealing with a different civilization. In the future, China's leaders will have PhDs and MBAs from American universities, he predicted.
19. (U) The Deputy Secretary has cleared this message.
SHIELDS
* guardian.co.uk © Guardian News and Media Limited 2010
S E C R E T SINGAPORE 000529
EO 12958 DECL: 06/04/2029
TAGS OVIP">OVIP (STEINBERG, JAMES B.), PREL, MNUC, ECON, SN, CH, KN
SUBJECT: DEPUTY SECRETARY STEINBERG'S MAY 30, 2009
CONVERSATION WITH SINGAPORE MINISTER MENTOR LEE KUAN YEW
Classified By: Charge d'Affaires Daniel L. Shields. Reason 1.4 (b) and (d).
Summary
1. Former prime minister of Singapore Lee Kuan Yew says China does not want North Korea to have nuclear weapons or to collapse, but would prefer the former. He doesn't believe Pyongyang will give up nuclear weapons as a form of defence and describes North Koreans as "psychopathic", but holds out hope for change under a new leader. Key passage highlighted in yellow.
1. (SBU) May 30, 2009; 6:30 p.m.; The Presidential Palace; Singapore.
2. (SBU) Participants: United States
-------------
The Deputy Secretary Glyn T. Davies, EAP
Acting Assistant Secretary Daniel L. Shields, CDA (Notetaker)
SINGAPORE
---------
Minister Mentor (MM) Lee Kuan Yew
Chee Hong Tat, Principal Private Secretary to MM
Cheryl Lee, Country Officer, Americas Directorate, MFA
3. (S) SUMMARY: Deputy Secretary Steinberg used his meeting with Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew to stress the importance of Chinese cooperation in addressing the North Korea nuclear issue and to elicit MM Lee's views on China and North Korea. MM Lee said the Chinese do not want North Korea to have nuclear weapons and do not want North Korea to collapse. If China has to choose, Beijing sees a North Korea with nuclear weapons as less bad than a North Korea that has collapsed. MM Lee asked Deputy Chief of the People's Liberation Army (PLA) General Staff Ma Xiaotian what China can do about North Korea. General Ma's answer was that "they can survive on their own." The Deputy Secretary noted that the DPRK could have a fair and attractive deal if it would change its approach. If not, North Korea faces a change of course by the United States, the ROK and Japan. MM Lee said he believes Japan may well "go nuclear." MM Lee also offered views on the Chinese economy, Taiwan, Chinese leaders, and U.S.-China relations. End Summary.
China and North Korea
---------------------
4. (S) Deputy Secretary Steinberg met with Singapore Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew on May 30 on the margins of the Shangri-La Dialogue, the annual international security forum held in Singapore. The Deputy Secretary used the meeting with MM Lee to stress the importance of Chinese cooperation in addressing the North Korea nuclear issue and to elicit MM Lee's views on China and North Korea. MM Lee said the Chinese do not want North Korea to have nuclear weapons. At the same time, the Chinese do not want North Korea, which China sees as a buffer state, to collapse. The ROK would take over in the North and China would face a U.S. presence at its border. If China has to choose, Beijing sees a North Korea with nuclear weapons as less bad for China than a North Korea that has collapsed, he stated.
5. (S) MM Lee said he asked Deputy Chief of the People's Liberation Army (PLA) General Staff Ma Xiaotian what China can do about North Korea. General Ma's Delphic answer was that "they can survive on their own." MM Lee said he interpreted this as meaning that even if China cut off aid, the DPRK leadership would survive. This is a leadership that has already taken actions like killing ROK Cabinet Members in Burma and shooting down a KAL flight. If they lose power, they will end up facing justice at The Hague, like Milosevic. They have been so isolated for so long that they have no friends, not even Russia. They have not trusted China since the Chinese began cultivating ties with the ROK, given China's interest in attracting foreign investment, he said. The Deputy Secretary noted that the DPRK could have a fair and attractive deal if it would change its approach. If not, North Korea faces a change of course by the United States, the ROK and Japan. MM Lee expressed worry about the effect on Iran if the DPRK persists. MM Lee said he believes the DPRK can be contained and will not proliferate, but Iran has very high ambitions, ties to Shiite communities outside Iran, and oil wealth.
6. (S) The Deputy Secretary noted that North Korea's decisions will have an impact in Japan. MM Lee said he believes Japan may well "go nuclear." The Chinese must have factored this into their calculations and concluded that the prospect of Japan with nuclear weapons is less bad than losing North Korea as a buffer state. The Chinese take a long-term view and must think that within a few years the DPRK's current leadership will be gone and there will be new leadership, with new thinking. But there will still be a North Korea, he said.
7. (S) MM Lee said he wishes the USG well in its efforts on North Korea, but he would be surprised if the North Koreans agree to give up nuclear weapons. They might give up a first-strike capacity, but they want nuclear weapons in case the USG decides to seek regime change. They are psychopathic types, with a "flabby old chap" for a leader who prances around stadiums seeking adulation. MM Lee noted that he had learned from living through three and a half years of Japanese occupation in Singapore that people will obey authorities who can deny them food, clothing and medicine.
8. (S) MM Lee said the ROK, after seeing what had happened with German unification, does not want immediate unification with the DPRK. There is "nothing there" in the DPRK, other than a military organization. Kim Jong-Il has already had a stroke. It is just a matter of time before he has another stroke. The next leader may not have the gumption or the bile of his father or grandfather. He may not be prepared to see people die like flies. China is calculating all this. They have their best men on the job. They want to help the United States to advance common objectives. But they do not want the South to take over the North, MM Lee said.
Chinese Economy
---------------
9. (C) Regarding the Chinese economy, MM Lee said the global economic crisis has hit many countries, but the feel on the ground differs considerably from place to place. The Chinese economy is reportedly in the doldrums, but when MM Lee visited Jiangsu Province on May 24, his impression was one of continued prosperity. Shanghai has been harder hit, with container port traffic down 30-35 percent, similar to the situation in Singapore. There is no sign of deep unrest in China. The Chinese are very confident they will be able to sustain eight percent growth. The government is pumping resources into the economy, with a focus on developing Western China. Whether such policies can be sustained for three to four years is unclear, but China can certainly sustain these policies for at least a year, he said.
10. (C) MM Lee stated that in the absence of a social safety net in China, the Chinese savings rate is 55 percent, exceeding even Singapore's 50 percent level. Consumption accounts for only 35 percent of Chinese GDP, as opposed to 70 percent of U.S. GDP. The Chinese leadership may be loath to shift permanently to a more consumption-oriented economy, but the leadership will do so temporarily, if only to avoid unrest. 20 million people have moved back to the countryside because of economic dislocations. The government is providing microfinance to facilitate the transition. The pragmatists are in charge. There is nothing Communist about it. They just want to preserve one party rule. The Deputy Secretary expressed concern that current Chinese policies designed to counter the economic crisis could undermine reform. MM Lee said this cannot be helped. China wants to prevent riots like the ones that happened in Guangzhou in March when Hong Kong-connected enterprises suddenly shut down, he said.
Taiwan
------
11. (C) The Deputy Secretary asked MM Lee for his assessment of Taiwan. MM Lee said former President Chen Shui-bian had left Taiwan in a weak economic position, which had enabled President Ma Ying-Jeou to come to power with his pledge to strengthen the economy through means including expanding the three links with China. In Beijing, former President Jiang Zemin was wedded to his eight-point approach, but President Hu Jintao was more flexible. Jiang wanted to show he was a great man by solving the Taiwan issue in his lifetime, but Hu is more patient and does not have any fixed timeline. In Chinese domestic politics, Hu had wanted Vice Premier Li Keqiang from the Communist Youth League to emerge as his successor, not Vice President Xi Jinping, but Hu did his calculations and accepted Xi when it became clear that Xi had the necessary backing from the rest of the leadership. Similarly, on Taiwan, Hu will be pragmatic. It does not matter to Hu if it takes 10 years or 20 or 30. The key is building links with Taiwan. As in the case of Hong Kong, if necessary the tap could be turned off, he said.
12. (C) In this context, MM Lee said, Hu could live with Ma's positions on the '92 consensus and on not addressing the reunification issue during his term in office. What mattered to Hu was that Taiwan not seek independence. If that happened, China has 1,000 missiles and is building its capacity to hold the U.S. fleet at a distance. The implicit question for Taiwan's leaders is if that is what they want, MM Lee said.
13. (C) MM Lee stated that the alternative is Mainland investment in Taiwan stocks and property. The Mainland has already assured Hong Kong that it will help out economically. The Mainland has not said this to Taiwan, but the Mainland's Taiwan Affairs Director, Wang Yi, did urge Chinese companies to invest in Taiwan. In four years Taiwan's economy will pick up and Ma will win re-election. The DPP lacks strong potential candidates. Su Zhen-chang is promising, but seems unlikely to be able to win. Meanwhile, even the traditionally DPP-supporting farmers in Taiwan's South need China's market for vegetables and other products. Taiwan's continued participation in the World Health Assembly depends on Beijing. Beijing's calculation seems to be to prevent Taiwan independence in the near term, then bring Taiwan "back to China," even if it takes 40 or 50 years. MM Lee said he is looking forward to visiting Fujian Province, where preparations are underway for a new southern economic area linked with Taiwan.
Xi Jinping
----------
14. (C) The Deputy Secretary asked if in the future a leader like Xi Jinping would continue the policies on Taiwan followed by Hu Jintao. MM Lee responded affirmatively. Xi is a princeling who succeeded despite being rusticated. When the party needed his talents, Xi was brought in as Shanghai Party Secretary. Xi is seen as a Jiang Zemin protege, but in another three and a half years Jiang's influence will be gone. The focus now is on maintaining the system. There are no more strongmen like Deng Xiaoping. Jiang did not like Hu, but could not stop him, because Hu had the backing of the system and he did not make mistakes.
Wang Qishan
-----------
15. (C) MM Lee said Vice Premier Wang Qishan, whom the MM saw in connection with celebrations in May of the 15th anniversary of Singapore-China Suzhou Industrial Park, is an exceptional talent, very assured and efficient. Wang handled SARS superbly when he was in Hainan. He excelled in coordinating the Beijing Olympics. Li Keqiang may not get the Premiership and the Party is looking for a way to keep Wang on past his 65th birthday until he is 70. MM Lee said he had met first Wang back in the 1990s but had forgotten their meeting. This time when they met, Wang told Lee he had reviewed the records of all Lee's meeting with Chinese leaders going back to the days of Deng Xiaoping to see how Lee's thinking had developed. Wang told Lee he respects him as a consistent man.
China's Rise
------------
16. (C) MM Lee said China is following an approach consistent with ideas in the Chinese television series "The Rise of Great Powers." The mistake of Germany and Japan had been their effort to challenge the existing order. The Chinese are not stupid; they have avoided this mistake. China's economy has surpassed other countries, with the exceptions of Japan and the United States. Even with those two countries, the gap is closing, with China growing at seven-nine percent annually, versus two-three percent in the United States and Japan. Overall GDP, not GDP per capita, is what matters in terms of power. China has four times the population of the United States. China is active in Latin America, Africa, and in the Gulf. Within hours, everything that is discussed in ASEAN meetings is known in Beijing, given China's close ties with Laos, Cambodia, and Burma, he stated.
17. (C) MM Lee said China will not reach the American level in terms of military capabilities any time soon, but is rapidly developing asymmetrical means to deter U.S. military power. China understands that its growth depends on imports, including energy, raw materials, and food. This is why China is working with South Africa on the China-Africa Development Fund. China also needs open sea lanes. Beijing is worried about its dependence on the Strait of Malacca and is moving to ease the dependence by means like a pipeline through Burma.
Build Ties with Young Chinese
-----------------------------
18. (C) MM Lee said the best course for the United States on China is to build ties with China's young people. China's best and brightest want to study in the United States, with the UK as the next option, then Japan. While they are there, it is important that they be treated as equals, with the cultural support they may need as foreigners. Why not have International Military Education and Training (IMET) programs for China? Why not have Chinese cadets at West Point alongside Vietnamese cadets and Indian cadets? America's advantage is that it can make use of the talent of the entire world, as in Silicon Valley. China still tends to try to keep the foreigners in Beijing and Shanghai. MM Lee noted that his own experience as a student in the UK had left him with an enduring fondness for the UK. When he spent two months at Harvard in 1968, an American professor had invited him home for Thanksgiving. This was not the sort of thing that happened in the UK, and Lee had realized he was dealing with a different civilization. In the future, China's leaders will have PhDs and MBAs from American universities, he predicted.
19. (U) The Deputy Secretary has cleared this message.
SHIELDS
* guardian.co.uk © Guardian News and Media Limited 2010
Wednesday, December 1, 2010
Why S'porean leaders believe in govt action
Dec 1, 2010
THINK-TANK
By Kishore Mahbubani, For The Straits Times
THE most withering look of contempt I have ever received in my life was from Dr Goh Keng Swee.
The year was 1971. I had just graduated with a first class honours degree in philosophy from the then-University of Singapore. In what must have been a rare honour, I was invited to a one-on-one conversation with Dr Goh, then-Minister of Defence, in his office at Pearl's Hill.
He made me a generous offer: join his team of 'whiz kids' in Mindef, a team that included the likes of Mr Lim Siong Guan and Mr Philip Yeo. He assured me that I would rise far and fast.
I was impressed, but replied, somewhat meekly: 'Dr Goh, I am afraid I cannot join Mindef.' He asked: 'Why not?' I replied: 'Because I am a pacifist.' With a withering look of contempt, he threw me out of his office.
Fortunately, I redeemed myself later. After some years in the Foreign Service, I realised how easy it was for a small state like Singapore to be bullied. I became a defence hawk. Perhaps that was why Dr Goh forgave me and continued to talk to me. Indeed, the most candid conversations I have ever had about Singapore's political and economic vulnerabilities have been with Dr Goh.
I have been thinking of Dr Goh again because I have been wondering what he would think of the current debate emerging once again between capitalism and socialism.
No, capitalism is not dead. It is alive and well. But the bloom is off the rose. As Ms Gillian Tett of The Financial Times puts it: 'The efficient market thesis is no longer in such vogue. Elaborate computer models do not command quite such reverence.'
In 1971, I was more socialist than capitalist. Indeed, socialism and pacifism seemed to fit together comfortably in one ideological package. Over time, I became more capitalist than socialist as I was swept along by the prevailing Reagan-Thatcher ideology of the 1980s. I came to believe that efficient markets could help reduce poverty by generating economic growth and creating jobs.
The global financial crisis of 2008-9 has brought to a screeching halt the Reagan-Thatcher revolution. Indeed, one of former United States president Ronald Reagan's most famous statements sounds downright stupid now: 'Government is not the solution; government is the problem.' Former US Federal Reserve chairman Alan Greenspan had heeded that principle in avoiding intervening in the markets to regulate new-fangled instruments like credit default swaps. This and several other factors led to the crisis. Now only an idiot would say 'markets know best'.
So far, most of the debate has been about the relative weights of markets and government in managing an economy. A deeper debate will emerge on the role of government in redistributing the fruits of economic growth and wealth.
The Reagan-Thatcher ideological revolution led many to believe that the best way to help the poor, and even the middle class, would be to let markets do their work. Sadly, this has not worked. Inequality has not diminished in advanced capitalist countries.
Indeed, by all indicators, America has become a much more unequal country since the 1980s. A recent study showed that the top 10 per cent of US households earn about 50 per cent of the country's total income. Three quarters of the growth in income during the eight years of the Mr George W. Bush's presidency went to the top 1 per cent of the population.
Amazingly, most Americans are unaware how unequal the country has become. A recent survey by Michael Norton and Dan Ariely found that Americans thought that the top 20 per cent should own just over 30 per cent of the country's wealth, and the bottom 40 per cent about 25 per cent. In reality, the top 20 per cent own about 85 per cent of the wealth and the bottom 40 per cent owns very near 0 per cent. Many at the very bottom have negative assets.
Of course, nothing like a socialist revolution appears imminent in America. There are many reasons for this: a deep distrust of socialism; ignorance of the actual wealth and income disparities; the continuing belief that any American can go from rags to riches if he tries hard enough. But there is no doubt that growing inequalities will generate new social and political stresses. One does not have to be a genius to forecast that.
Why is all this relevant to Singapore? The simple answer is that inequality levels in Singapore are also rising. Singapore's Gini Coefficient (if government transfer payments are excluded) is 42.5, exceeded only by Hong Kong's 43.4 among countries or territories with very high human development. (A value of 0 represents absolute equality and 100 absolute inequality).
Unlike America, however, Singapore has a whole slew of policies to help people at the bottom - from subsidised housing and health care to virtually free education, as well as a carefully managed workfare and welfare system. In many respects, Singapore remains quite socialist in its orientation, reflecting the democratic socialist ideals of Singapore's founding fathers, including Dr Goh. They once co-authored a book in the 1970s titled Socialism That Works, referring to the socio-economic system they had created.
Based on government surveys, Singaporean households need a minimum of $1,700 to cover basic costs of living like food and utilities. Yet the lowest 20 per cent of households earned an average of $1,274 per month in 2007-8. At some point, this inequality will create stresses, as government leaders have acknowledged in justifying schemes like Workfare, Jobs Credit, HDB upgrades and massive expenditure on Continuing Education.
So, if Dr Goh were alive today, would he pragmatically and pre-emptively intervene to improve the lot of people at the bottom or would he assume the market would solve all problems?
My guess is that he would intervene pre-emptively.
The writer is the dean of the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy, National University of Singapore. Think-Tank is a weekly column rotated among eight leading figures in Singapore's tertiary and research institutions.
THINK-TANK
By Kishore Mahbubani, For The Straits Times
THE most withering look of contempt I have ever received in my life was from Dr Goh Keng Swee.
The year was 1971. I had just graduated with a first class honours degree in philosophy from the then-University of Singapore. In what must have been a rare honour, I was invited to a one-on-one conversation with Dr Goh, then-Minister of Defence, in his office at Pearl's Hill.
He made me a generous offer: join his team of 'whiz kids' in Mindef, a team that included the likes of Mr Lim Siong Guan and Mr Philip Yeo. He assured me that I would rise far and fast.
I was impressed, but replied, somewhat meekly: 'Dr Goh, I am afraid I cannot join Mindef.' He asked: 'Why not?' I replied: 'Because I am a pacifist.' With a withering look of contempt, he threw me out of his office.
Fortunately, I redeemed myself later. After some years in the Foreign Service, I realised how easy it was for a small state like Singapore to be bullied. I became a defence hawk. Perhaps that was why Dr Goh forgave me and continued to talk to me. Indeed, the most candid conversations I have ever had about Singapore's political and economic vulnerabilities have been with Dr Goh.
I have been thinking of Dr Goh again because I have been wondering what he would think of the current debate emerging once again between capitalism and socialism.
No, capitalism is not dead. It is alive and well. But the bloom is off the rose. As Ms Gillian Tett of The Financial Times puts it: 'The efficient market thesis is no longer in such vogue. Elaborate computer models do not command quite such reverence.'
In 1971, I was more socialist than capitalist. Indeed, socialism and pacifism seemed to fit together comfortably in one ideological package. Over time, I became more capitalist than socialist as I was swept along by the prevailing Reagan-Thatcher ideology of the 1980s. I came to believe that efficient markets could help reduce poverty by generating economic growth and creating jobs.
The global financial crisis of 2008-9 has brought to a screeching halt the Reagan-Thatcher revolution. Indeed, one of former United States president Ronald Reagan's most famous statements sounds downright stupid now: 'Government is not the solution; government is the problem.' Former US Federal Reserve chairman Alan Greenspan had heeded that principle in avoiding intervening in the markets to regulate new-fangled instruments like credit default swaps. This and several other factors led to the crisis. Now only an idiot would say 'markets know best'.
So far, most of the debate has been about the relative weights of markets and government in managing an economy. A deeper debate will emerge on the role of government in redistributing the fruits of economic growth and wealth.
The Reagan-Thatcher ideological revolution led many to believe that the best way to help the poor, and even the middle class, would be to let markets do their work. Sadly, this has not worked. Inequality has not diminished in advanced capitalist countries.
Indeed, by all indicators, America has become a much more unequal country since the 1980s. A recent study showed that the top 10 per cent of US households earn about 50 per cent of the country's total income. Three quarters of the growth in income during the eight years of the Mr George W. Bush's presidency went to the top 1 per cent of the population.
Amazingly, most Americans are unaware how unequal the country has become. A recent survey by Michael Norton and Dan Ariely found that Americans thought that the top 20 per cent should own just over 30 per cent of the country's wealth, and the bottom 40 per cent about 25 per cent. In reality, the top 20 per cent own about 85 per cent of the wealth and the bottom 40 per cent owns very near 0 per cent. Many at the very bottom have negative assets.
Of course, nothing like a socialist revolution appears imminent in America. There are many reasons for this: a deep distrust of socialism; ignorance of the actual wealth and income disparities; the continuing belief that any American can go from rags to riches if he tries hard enough. But there is no doubt that growing inequalities will generate new social and political stresses. One does not have to be a genius to forecast that.
Why is all this relevant to Singapore? The simple answer is that inequality levels in Singapore are also rising. Singapore's Gini Coefficient (if government transfer payments are excluded) is 42.5, exceeded only by Hong Kong's 43.4 among countries or territories with very high human development. (A value of 0 represents absolute equality and 100 absolute inequality).
Unlike America, however, Singapore has a whole slew of policies to help people at the bottom - from subsidised housing and health care to virtually free education, as well as a carefully managed workfare and welfare system. In many respects, Singapore remains quite socialist in its orientation, reflecting the democratic socialist ideals of Singapore's founding fathers, including Dr Goh. They once co-authored a book in the 1970s titled Socialism That Works, referring to the socio-economic system they had created.
Based on government surveys, Singaporean households need a minimum of $1,700 to cover basic costs of living like food and utilities. Yet the lowest 20 per cent of households earned an average of $1,274 per month in 2007-8. At some point, this inequality will create stresses, as government leaders have acknowledged in justifying schemes like Workfare, Jobs Credit, HDB upgrades and massive expenditure on Continuing Education.
So, if Dr Goh were alive today, would he pragmatically and pre-emptively intervene to improve the lot of people at the bottom or would he assume the market would solve all problems?
My guess is that he would intervene pre-emptively.
The writer is the dean of the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy, National University of Singapore. Think-Tank is a weekly column rotated among eight leading figures in Singapore's tertiary and research institutions.
Make undergrads pay full fees
Dec 1, 2010
THE ST INTERVIEW
It's only morally right, says vice-chancellor of private British varsity
By Tan Hui Yee
AS BRITISH universities erupt in angry student protests at funding cuts and higher tuition fees, one vice-chancellor bravely proffers the view that the cuts are long overdue.
In fact, he thinks the British government should stop giving universities any money at all - save for expensive courses such as medicine - and that Singapore should do the same thing.
'I think it's morally right,' says Dr Terence Kealey, vice-chancellor of the University of Buckingham. The student, he says, benefits most from university education as he earns a 'graduate premium' of about £160,000 (S$330,000) over his lifetime.
'If you are going to earn £160,000 more... because you have been to university, it would seem reasonable that you pay for your university education,' he says.
The declaration is fitting, coming from the 58-year-old biochemist who runs Britain's only private university. The small institute - with just over 1,000 students - takes pride in its freedom to operate without government influence.
In town recently to give a talk hosted by the Economic Society of Singapore, he says privatising universities 'empowers' students to demand better education. 'If the students are paying directly for their own education, they are going to start saying to the university, 'Hey, why am I only getting two lectures a week? Why I am only getting one seminar a week?''
Universities will be forced to answer to their new paymasters. 'We'll get a complete reorientation of academics much more around the needs of students,' he says.
But won't such an unsubsidised full-fee system deter many deserving students who cannot afford it?
Not if it is supported by a system of loans, grants and scholarships, he retorts.
[Comment: Singapore's system is already supported by govt grants and various scholarships from private and public sources.]
'I'm prepared to believe that a developing nation might need a boost from the government to set up such institutions. But once a society is as rich as Singapore, the idea that the average Singaporean can't afford to pay for his university education, either immediately or with a loan system, is just clearly not true,' he maintains.
He says having a full fee-paying system will lead to better universities. The current academic system, he thinks, is skewed towards rewarding research. It benefits academics more than students.
Yet universities' main job is to teach. 'The average student only has one go at being an undergraduate. You can't go to (the University of) Warwick and say, 'Well, that was no good, I will now spend another three years at Durham University or the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.'
'The student only has that one bite of that teaching cherry. And if the teaching is not good, then he is actually being robbed of something.'
In contrast, he says, research 'can take place anywhere'. 'Lots of the best research does not take place in universities,' he claims. 'It takes place in institutions, charitable laboratories, foundation laboratories and (private) industries.'
The self-professed libertarian has published two books - the most recent being the 2008 publication Sex, Science And Profits - which argue that the private and philanthropic sectors in Britain, the United States and even Singapore are responsible for more scientific and technological innovation than what they are given credit for. Both books also argue that government funding for science crowds out private activity rather than add to it.
To be fair, he says, it is possible and even desirable for both research and teaching to be done well within a university. 'It helps keep teaching and scholarship up to date and provides a richer environment for the students.'
However, within the British higher education system at least, the research-centred incentives turn it into a 'zero sum game' at the expense of teaching. The only exceptions are Oxford and Cambridge, which he thinks shine on both counts.
He concedes that that may be because they are relatively well-endowed. Cambridge has an endowment fund of £4 billion and Oxford £3 billion. These sums are about four times that held by the National University of Singapore, which had S$2.01 billion in its kitty in March this year.
'That tells us that if universities want to do a proper job, they ought to start doing something about endowments. Oxford and Cambridge are special. But rather than dismiss them, we should all be trying to model ourselves on them.'
Ask him how universities should grow their endowment funds, and he draws out his breath in a long baritone. 'Now that's difficult because the only country that has succeeded in doing that really well is the United States of America.'
He thinks it is because 'when you pay a lot of money to do something, you tend to value it greatly'.
'The paradox is, the more expensive the (university) fees, the more likely it is that people want to donate (to the university) afterwards.'
He cites as evidence the schooling system in 19th-century England, where parents had to pay full fees to educate their charges. 'Levels of attendance went up, levels of truancy went down, the amount of homework that parents demanded and made sure their children did went up.'
To him, paying fees is an expression of ownership that heightens 'the mutual commitment to the activity'.
In contrast, when university education is funded through taxes and made free to students, 'you actually institutionalise irresponsibility'. It also makes people less inclined to donate to universities.
But how will his 'pull out and make them pay up' endowment-raising strategy play out in a country like Singapore, which was placed 91st out of 153 countries earlier this year in terms of its people's willingness to donate time and money?
He sighs and says: 'It's one of the prices you pay for a very paternalistic society.' One of the consequences of living in a society like Singapore, where 'the state is seen as the ultimate provider, like a sort of Earth mother', is that it takes away from people 'the belief in the responsibility of providing these goods themselves', he says.
To make his point, he cites the 'fabulous' art galleries in the United States.
'Almost all the art galleries in America, like The Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York or the National Gallery of Art in Washington, are supplied by philanthropists to compensate for the lack of government funding...The art galleries in America are the best in the world.'
But he thinks the same may yet happen in Singapore.
'If the Singapore Government identified an area where it just wouldn't support...if it said, 'If the people in Singapore want a symphony orchestra, they are going to have to pay for it themselves', I bet you people will pay for it.'
[Social services?]
Some multimillionaire will cough up the money as long as he gets due recognition for the donation, he predicts.
He concedes that each tycoon will have his or her agenda. But then, 'everyone has an agenda; the government has an agenda'. In the end, he says, all these competing interests even out as long as there are enough diverse sources of funds. Contrary to what people think, he says, market-based societies support rather than kill philanthropy. A nation's 'moral health' is tied intimately to its 'economic health'.
'Markets work only if - and Singapore is a perfect example - people are honest, trustworthy, if their word is their bond... Market economies are based on societies of law-abiding, morally good people.'
Hence, a healthy market society produces rich people 'animated by these moral goods'.
'Like everyone else, they want recognition,' he says. 'That spills over very quickly into philanthropy.'
With the right tax incentives, 'a country like Singapore can produce philanthropy in big amounts'.
Provided, of course, the Government doesn't crowd them out.
tanhy@sph.com.sg
THE ST INTERVIEW
It's only morally right, says vice-chancellor of private British varsity
By Tan Hui Yee
AS BRITISH universities erupt in angry student protests at funding cuts and higher tuition fees, one vice-chancellor bravely proffers the view that the cuts are long overdue.
In fact, he thinks the British government should stop giving universities any money at all - save for expensive courses such as medicine - and that Singapore should do the same thing.
'I think it's morally right,' says Dr Terence Kealey, vice-chancellor of the University of Buckingham. The student, he says, benefits most from university education as he earns a 'graduate premium' of about £160,000 (S$330,000) over his lifetime.
'If you are going to earn £160,000 more... because you have been to university, it would seem reasonable that you pay for your university education,' he says.
The declaration is fitting, coming from the 58-year-old biochemist who runs Britain's only private university. The small institute - with just over 1,000 students - takes pride in its freedom to operate without government influence.
In town recently to give a talk hosted by the Economic Society of Singapore, he says privatising universities 'empowers' students to demand better education. 'If the students are paying directly for their own education, they are going to start saying to the university, 'Hey, why am I only getting two lectures a week? Why I am only getting one seminar a week?''
Universities will be forced to answer to their new paymasters. 'We'll get a complete reorientation of academics much more around the needs of students,' he says.
But won't such an unsubsidised full-fee system deter many deserving students who cannot afford it?
Not if it is supported by a system of loans, grants and scholarships, he retorts.
[Comment: Singapore's system is already supported by govt grants and various scholarships from private and public sources.]
'I'm prepared to believe that a developing nation might need a boost from the government to set up such institutions. But once a society is as rich as Singapore, the idea that the average Singaporean can't afford to pay for his university education, either immediately or with a loan system, is just clearly not true,' he maintains.
He says having a full fee-paying system will lead to better universities. The current academic system, he thinks, is skewed towards rewarding research. It benefits academics more than students.
Yet universities' main job is to teach. 'The average student only has one go at being an undergraduate. You can't go to (the University of) Warwick and say, 'Well, that was no good, I will now spend another three years at Durham University or the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.'
'The student only has that one bite of that teaching cherry. And if the teaching is not good, then he is actually being robbed of something.'
In contrast, he says, research 'can take place anywhere'. 'Lots of the best research does not take place in universities,' he claims. 'It takes place in institutions, charitable laboratories, foundation laboratories and (private) industries.'
The self-professed libertarian has published two books - the most recent being the 2008 publication Sex, Science And Profits - which argue that the private and philanthropic sectors in Britain, the United States and even Singapore are responsible for more scientific and technological innovation than what they are given credit for. Both books also argue that government funding for science crowds out private activity rather than add to it.
To be fair, he says, it is possible and even desirable for both research and teaching to be done well within a university. 'It helps keep teaching and scholarship up to date and provides a richer environment for the students.'
However, within the British higher education system at least, the research-centred incentives turn it into a 'zero sum game' at the expense of teaching. The only exceptions are Oxford and Cambridge, which he thinks shine on both counts.
He concedes that that may be because they are relatively well-endowed. Cambridge has an endowment fund of £4 billion and Oxford £3 billion. These sums are about four times that held by the National University of Singapore, which had S$2.01 billion in its kitty in March this year.
'That tells us that if universities want to do a proper job, they ought to start doing something about endowments. Oxford and Cambridge are special. But rather than dismiss them, we should all be trying to model ourselves on them.'
Ask him how universities should grow their endowment funds, and he draws out his breath in a long baritone. 'Now that's difficult because the only country that has succeeded in doing that really well is the United States of America.'
He thinks it is because 'when you pay a lot of money to do something, you tend to value it greatly'.
'The paradox is, the more expensive the (university) fees, the more likely it is that people want to donate (to the university) afterwards.'
He cites as evidence the schooling system in 19th-century England, where parents had to pay full fees to educate their charges. 'Levels of attendance went up, levels of truancy went down, the amount of homework that parents demanded and made sure their children did went up.'
To him, paying fees is an expression of ownership that heightens 'the mutual commitment to the activity'.
In contrast, when university education is funded through taxes and made free to students, 'you actually institutionalise irresponsibility'. It also makes people less inclined to donate to universities.
But how will his 'pull out and make them pay up' endowment-raising strategy play out in a country like Singapore, which was placed 91st out of 153 countries earlier this year in terms of its people's willingness to donate time and money?
He sighs and says: 'It's one of the prices you pay for a very paternalistic society.' One of the consequences of living in a society like Singapore, where 'the state is seen as the ultimate provider, like a sort of Earth mother', is that it takes away from people 'the belief in the responsibility of providing these goods themselves', he says.
To make his point, he cites the 'fabulous' art galleries in the United States.
'Almost all the art galleries in America, like The Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York or the National Gallery of Art in Washington, are supplied by philanthropists to compensate for the lack of government funding...The art galleries in America are the best in the world.'
But he thinks the same may yet happen in Singapore.
'If the Singapore Government identified an area where it just wouldn't support...if it said, 'If the people in Singapore want a symphony orchestra, they are going to have to pay for it themselves', I bet you people will pay for it.'
[Social services?]
Some multimillionaire will cough up the money as long as he gets due recognition for the donation, he predicts.
He concedes that each tycoon will have his or her agenda. But then, 'everyone has an agenda; the government has an agenda'. In the end, he says, all these competing interests even out as long as there are enough diverse sources of funds. Contrary to what people think, he says, market-based societies support rather than kill philanthropy. A nation's 'moral health' is tied intimately to its 'economic health'.
'Markets work only if - and Singapore is a perfect example - people are honest, trustworthy, if their word is their bond... Market economies are based on societies of law-abiding, morally good people.'
Hence, a healthy market society produces rich people 'animated by these moral goods'.
'Like everyone else, they want recognition,' he says. 'That spills over very quickly into philanthropy.'
With the right tax incentives, 'a country like Singapore can produce philanthropy in big amounts'.
Provided, of course, the Government doesn't crowd them out.
tanhy@sph.com.sg
100-Storey KL tower project
Nov 30, 2010
Mahathir slams KL tower project in about-turn
KUALA LUMPUR: Former Malaysian prime minister Mahathir Mohamad yesterday criticised plans for a 100-storey mega tower in the capital, admitting he does not want the proposed skyscraper to outshine the 88-storey Petronas Twin Towers.
'I must admit I am biased... And I would like to retain it (Petronas Twin Towers) as the tallest building in Malaysia.
'At the moment, we don't need any tower higher than that. We should build it (Warisan Merdeka) a little bit later. Maybe, when I'm not around,' the 85-year-old added in jest at a gathering of industry leaders.
The comments indicate that Tun Dr Mahathir, who had initially said the RM5 billion (S$2.1 billion) Warisan Merdeka project was a good idea as it created jobs and business opportunities, is now making an about-turn on the issue.
The Petronas Twin Towers complex in Kuala Lumpur was Dr Mahathir's brainchild and he was known during his 22 years in power for supporting similar mega projects.
He oversaw the building of a multibillion-dollar administrative capital, Putrajaya, and launched the national carmaker Proton during his marathon premiership.
The Twin Towers complex, the world's tallest building when completed in 1998, was featured a year later in the climax of the Hollywood heist movie Entrapment, starring Sean Connery and Catherine Zeta-Jones.
Dr Mahathir also said the new building would create a property glut in the Klang Valley.
'I see a lot of 'for sale' and 'for rent' signs when I walk around. That means we already have a lot of buildings,' he said.
'We may not be building like crazy, but we are crazy building.'
The government's plan to build the new 100-storey skyscraper by 2015 has sparked an outcry among Malaysians, who feel that taxpayers' money would be better spent on education, health care and public transport.
On Facebook, more than 263,000 people have signed an online petition against Prime Minister Najib Razak's plan.
Datuk Seri Najib, who wants the new tower built as part of an ambitious new infrastructure push, has said the project can become a business hub and noted that the Twin Towers originally attracted similar criticism.
AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE, THE STAR/ASIA NEWS NETWORK
Najib defends 100-storey KL tower
KUALA LUMPUR - MALAYSIA'S prime minister has defended a plan to construct a US$1.6 billion (S$2.1 billion), 100-story tower in Kuala Lumpur, saying it will contribute to long-term development of the city.
However, Premier Najib Razak says the project's owners must first ensure the building is 'financially viable' and will provide economic opportunities.
Mr Najib told reporters on Tuesday that 'it is a long-term project for 10 years and beyond, not for one or two years.'
Critics have slammed the privately financed project in downtown Kuala Lumpur as an unnecessary extravagance at a time of belt-tightening and rising prices.
Even former Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad, who presided over several massive infrastructure projects during his time in office, has been critical. -- AP
[Dr M led the way with mega-ego projects. Now he not happy when others want similar monuments to themselves.]
Mahathir slams KL tower project in about-turn
KUALA LUMPUR: Former Malaysian prime minister Mahathir Mohamad yesterday criticised plans for a 100-storey mega tower in the capital, admitting he does not want the proposed skyscraper to outshine the 88-storey Petronas Twin Towers.
'I must admit I am biased... And I would like to retain it (Petronas Twin Towers) as the tallest building in Malaysia.
'At the moment, we don't need any tower higher than that. We should build it (Warisan Merdeka) a little bit later. Maybe, when I'm not around,' the 85-year-old added in jest at a gathering of industry leaders.
The comments indicate that Tun Dr Mahathir, who had initially said the RM5 billion (S$2.1 billion) Warisan Merdeka project was a good idea as it created jobs and business opportunities, is now making an about-turn on the issue.
The Petronas Twin Towers complex in Kuala Lumpur was Dr Mahathir's brainchild and he was known during his 22 years in power for supporting similar mega projects.
He oversaw the building of a multibillion-dollar administrative capital, Putrajaya, and launched the national carmaker Proton during his marathon premiership.
The Twin Towers complex, the world's tallest building when completed in 1998, was featured a year later in the climax of the Hollywood heist movie Entrapment, starring Sean Connery and Catherine Zeta-Jones.
Dr Mahathir also said the new building would create a property glut in the Klang Valley.
'I see a lot of 'for sale' and 'for rent' signs when I walk around. That means we already have a lot of buildings,' he said.
'We may not be building like crazy, but we are crazy building.'
The government's plan to build the new 100-storey skyscraper by 2015 has sparked an outcry among Malaysians, who feel that taxpayers' money would be better spent on education, health care and public transport.
On Facebook, more than 263,000 people have signed an online petition against Prime Minister Najib Razak's plan.
Datuk Seri Najib, who wants the new tower built as part of an ambitious new infrastructure push, has said the project can become a business hub and noted that the Twin Towers originally attracted similar criticism.
AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE, THE STAR/ASIA NEWS NETWORK
Najib defends 100-storey KL tower
KUALA LUMPUR - MALAYSIA'S prime minister has defended a plan to construct a US$1.6 billion (S$2.1 billion), 100-story tower in Kuala Lumpur, saying it will contribute to long-term development of the city.
However, Premier Najib Razak says the project's owners must first ensure the building is 'financially viable' and will provide economic opportunities.
Mr Najib told reporters on Tuesday that 'it is a long-term project for 10 years and beyond, not for one or two years.'
Critics have slammed the privately financed project in downtown Kuala Lumpur as an unnecessary extravagance at a time of belt-tightening and rising prices.
Even former Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad, who presided over several massive infrastructure projects during his time in office, has been critical. -- AP
[Dr M led the way with mega-ego projects. Now he not happy when others want similar monuments to themselves.]
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)