Sunday, December 5, 2010

A true-blue S'porean's view of China

Dec 5, 2010

My ancestors may hail from the mainland but I have not an iota of Chinese chauvinism

By Lee Wei Ling

I picked up Journeys: An Anthology Of Short Stories by my close friend Ho Minfong the other day.

A mixture of memoir and fiction, it has a chapter entitled 'Home Coming', in which she narrates how 40 members of her family - led by her father, the late businessman Ho Rih Hwa - once visited Sunhwei, their ancestral village in Guangdong province.

I learnt from Minfong's book that the government of the Qing dynasty had been harsh towards those of its subjects who had left China. In 1740, in response to a Dutch apology for the massacre of Chinese workers in Java, the Qianlong Emperor said that China had washed its hands of the overseas Chinese. 'These people are deserters of the celestial empire, they deserted their ancestral tombs and sought benefits overseas, and the Court is not interested in them,' he said.

But the Chinese government was also calculating. Rich Chinese migrants who returned to China and gave money to charitable causes there were treated with courtesy and respect. The famous philanthropist Tan Kah Kee, for example, donated large sums of money to education in China and was declared a good son of the country.

My father is a fourth-generation descendant of migrants from the once impoverished Hakka village of Dabu in Guangdong. My mother was a fifth-generation descendant of migrants from Tong'an county in Fujian province.

Their families had adapted to the language, cuisine and attire of Malaya and Singapore. They transmitted Chinese culture and values to their descendents through Baba Malay, a patois consisting of Malay and Indonesian words mixed with some Chinese words. They had a distinct Peranakan culture, while adhering to Chinese practices like ancestor worship and Taoism.

By contrast, Mingfong's family had clung to the Chinese language and traditions. So it feels natural for her to write: 'Stubbornly and single-mindedly, we overseas Chinese clung to things Chinese.'

I have never felt the urge to visit my ancestral hometown, though I know I must have distant cousins there. My paternal great great- grandfather Lee Bok Boon had returned to China after he had made enough money in these parts.

Fortunately for me, his wife, my great great-grandmother, refused to leave Singapore. She had been born here and did not wish to abandon it for a country she had never seen. So, she hid herself and her children, and Lee Bok Boon had to return to Dabu alone.

There he married again, built a large house, and bought himself a minor mandarinate. I do not think well of Lee Bok Boon. Buying a mandarinate seems to me questionable, though it was accepted practice in those times.

[I would be more forgiving. His "chuavism/patriotism" pulled him back to his home. That was his dream, ambition, desire. He pursued it and lived his dream. If I had an issue with his action, it would have been the "married again" part. Did he start another family there?]


Some years ago, Chinese officials presented my father, Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew, with his family genealogy. It showed that one ancestor, six generations removed, had been a military governor of Guangsi province.

Chinese officials also offered to arrange for my father to visit Dabu. He declined, explaining that our neighbours suspect Singapore of being a Chinese country, and his visiting his ancestral hometown might be seen as evidence of Chinese chauvinism.

The local authorities in Dabu have converted Lee Bok Boon's home into a tourist attraction. The Char Yong Association in Singapore, a Hakka clan association, has donated money to renovate the house. Chinese nationals as well as Hakka Singaporeans visit it.

Indeed, I'm told there is a big signboard on the road leading to the premises, with an arrow pointing in the direction of 'Lee Kuan Yew's ancestral home'. When my brother Lee Hsien Loong became Prime Minister, his name was added to the signboard.

The genealogy of my mother's Kwa family reveals an ancestor, Ke Qingwen, who successfully sat the Imperial Examination in 1024 and was awarded the degree of advance scholar. He was later appointed second-class secretary to the board of agriculture. Because of this, he was accorded the status of the earliest ancestor in the Kwa (Ke) genealogical record.

My cousin, historian Kwa Chong Guan, has visited Tong'an and has met our distant relatives there. He made a donation to the Kwa ancestral temple. When he next visited Tong'an, he found the temple spruced up, and he received a warm welcome.

My nine years in a Chinese school probably did plant a seed of Chinese chauvinism in my mind, along with an appreciation of Chinese culture. But my first visit to China in 1976 led me to conclude that it was an arrogant country. I had heard repeatedly on that visit that China was the only country in the world with '5,000 years of uninterrupted glorious history' (a phrase that had also been used often by my Chinese teachers here). The Chinese people, we were told, were confident that China will one day, again, be the centre of the world.

Mao Zedong was still alive when I first visited China. I saw poverty and filth everywhere, as well as political slogans written in big Chinese characters pasted on walls. We visited Mao's World War II base in Yan'an, and heard the tour guide extol the heroes of the Long March, including Zhou Enlai's stuffed horse. My father listened attentively but my mother and I wandered off.

What I saw and felt during that trip ripped out whatever little Chinese chauvinism there was in me. I concluded that '5,000 years of uninterrupted glorious history' had led the Chinese to look backwards, not forwards, and was impeding their progress.

[My issue with 5000 years of history is - so what? How do I get to be proud of that? Suppose I am the direct descendant of Confucius. Do I have a right to proud of him? Of my heritage? Do I think like him? Am I smart like him? Do I see the world and its affairs with his perceptiveness and clarity of thought? Am I wise like him? Should people respect me, give me favours and privileges because I am his descendant? Do I have the right to say, "listen to me for I am the direct descendant of Confucius and I know what I am saying?"

Does having 5000 years of history give me the right to tell other races/nationalities, "as a race we Chinese are smarter than you and will once again rule the world?"

In all probability, China may one day dominate the world but it will not be because of 5000 years of uninterrupted history. That's just good bureaucracy, good record keeping, and some good fortune. Chinese people will outnumber any other races, but that's just fertility and runaway birth control. Maybe it's because of good bureaucracy, good crop and agriculture management (There was a secretary of Agriculture in China in the 11th century! And possibly even earlier!). Or maybe simply good governance. That may be something to learn, but if we have forgotten to practice, there is little to be proud of. ]


That all changed, of course, when Deng Xiaoping, a great man, assumed power in China. He visited Singapore in 1978, saw what we had accomplished, and determined that China could do the same.

I have accompanied my father to China many times since 1976, including on trips last year and this. I can see that China has undergone tremendous transformations. I have no doubt it will succeed further. But I don't feel anything in particular about China's success - no swelling of pride. I see China through the prism of my home, Singapore.

I am a Chinese Singaporean - with the stress on the noun.


The writer is director of the National Neuroscience Institute.

IRs' impact: Malaysian DPM seeks study

Dec 5, 2010

Bogor, Indonesia - Malaysian Deputy Prime Minister Muhyiddin Yassin has said a thorough study is needed to look at the impact arising from Malaysians gambling at Singapore's two integrated resorts (IRs).

He said such a study should be undertaken before any measure, including the imposition of a levy, is introduced.

Tan Sri Muhyiddin, speaking yesterday at the end of a four-day visit to Indonesia, was asked to comment on the proposal by Barisan Nasional Youth and the Johor Malaysian Chinese Association (MCA) Youth that the federal government move to prevent outflow of funds to Singapore and social problems from setting in.

'If they choose to gamble, what business does the government have in preventing and so on? Is the imposition of the levy a reasonable move? This we have to study deeply. Or there are other initiatives that we can implement, to be looked at not only from the economic aspect,' Mr Muhyiddin said. He added that social and community leadership, and political parties, may have a role to play in tackling the issue.

Personally, he said, he would not encourage anyone to gamble in Malaysia or Singapore.

The government has no restriction on anyone going to Singapore to gamble - but there is a restriction on Muslims gambling in Genting Highland.

There have been several reports in Malaysian media recently about people being lured to gamble in the IRs through various means, including free transportation, food and pocket money.

Last month, MCA Youth chief Wee Ka Siong expressed concern over the increasing number of such 'free tours', saying that they were organised not only from Johor but also from as far north as Penang.

Another Johor state assemblyman, Datuk Tee Siew Kiong, claimed that some 3,000 Malaysians took buses to Singapore daily to gamble away RM7 million (S$3 million) at the IRs. He claimed that 30 buses made the round trip daily, with seven of those buses coming from Singapore.

Mr Muhyiddin yesterday said the study should look at whether the trend of people going to gamble in Singapore was temporary.

'From the social aspect, the implication is bad. This is because it involves a neighbouring country. We can't make hasty decisions, we have to study the short-term and long-term impact,' he said.

Bernama

[Since M'sia has Genting, the attraction may be more than just the gambling. Maybe people are using the free transport to get to Sentosa or Downtown Singapore. But certainly, M'sia has every right to be concerned about its citizen and every right to try to do something about it. Just as when M'sian subsidised fuel inadvertently undermined SG's traffic control policy, we instituted the half- then three-quarter tank rule to reduce the instances of people crossing the causeway for cheap fuel. However, despite Genting attracting thousands of S'poreans to their casinos, SG govt had never attempted to curtail them.

Certainly, the opportunity to gamble either here or at Genting has always been opened to M'sian as long as they are not Malay. The IRs here are only a new option for the M'sia Malays. If the non-Malays are preferring our IRs, perhaps there are other reasons?]

Just one class of wards will do

Dec 4, 2010
 
With means testing, we don't need many classes of subsidised wards
 
By Salma Khalik

HEALTH-CARE standards evolve over time, and the latest example is in the C class ward of the new Khoo Teck Puat Hospital (KTPH) in Yishun.

The traditional C class hospital ward has rows of beds lined up dormitory style in a long room, with toilets and shower areas along common corridors outside.

In contrast, the new C class ward, while housing 10 patients per room, groups five patients in an enclosed area with en suite toilet and shower facilities. The ward is laid out so each bed has a window to allow light and ventilation.

The new C class ward at KTPH is to be replicated in the Jurong General Hospital, due to be ready by 2014.

The new C wards prompt the question of just why there is even a need to have C class wards, and why there is a need to differentiate between the B and C classes of subsidised wards.

The quick answer is contained in the 1993 White Paper on Affordable Health Care. This suggested differentiating hospital wards by 'ambience and creature comfort', with different number of beds per room and different amount of floor space per bed.

The idea was to reduce creature comforts in C class wards to curb demand for these highly-subsidised beds, without compromising on medical care. In other words, rationing by discomfort.

But now that means testing has been introduced, there is a better way to ration demand for subsidised beds. It is timely to rethink the need for different classes of subsidised wards.

The current system of hospital bed classes is complicated, to say the least.

Today, most public hospitals have six ward classes. The three private wards are: A+ with one patient per room and a sitting room attached; A with one or two patients per room; B1 which houses four patients per air-conditioned room.

There are three subsidised wards:
  • B2+ which has five people sharing an air-conditioned room and 50 per cent subsidy.
  • B2 with six people sharing a non air-conditioned room with 50-65 per cent subsidy.
  • C with eight to 12 people in a dormitory-style ward with no air-conditioning. The ward is open-concept and separated from other wards by a waist-high wall. They are subsidised 65-80 per cent.
It looks, and is, confusing.

No wonder patients today need financial counselling to understand their choices and likely bills. Hospitals also have to set up a complex administrative procedure to handle the different ward classes.

The system of having multiple subsidised ward classes is likely to become less relevant in future.

For one thing, new hospitals in Yishun and Jurong are building C and B2 class wards that resemble private B1 class wards - with ensuite toilets and bathrooms, much more space between beds, and fewer beds per ward. The only physical difference is air-conditioning.

The change came about for a very practical - and vital - reason.

There was a major rethink on ward sizes following Sars in 2003, when the severe acute respiratory syndrome bug spread within large hospital wards.

Administrators realised the virtues of smaller, self-contained wards to ring-fence or quarantine a disease. It was harder to introduce infection control in open-concept C class wards.

Today, infection control remains a critical issue. Smaller wards with fewer patients reduce the risk of cross-infection and make it easier to isolate affected patients. This is the key reason wards in new hospitals like the KTPH and the new Jurong General will have fewer patients per ward, even in C class.

If having fewer patients share a room and bathroom facilities helps keep hospital-acquired infections to a minimum, then that should be the type of wards built. And if most new subsidised wards built in future will be self-contained rooms with ensuite facilities, there is a need to rethink the old model of having so many subsidised ward classes.

Instead, the Ministry of Health can streamline the hospital bed system by doing away with the B2 wards and having just one C class of subsidised ward.

The strongest argument for this is that the old justification of rationing demand for hospital beds by discomfort is no longer needed, as patients now undergo means testing, and subsidy rates vary according to their income levels.

Patients need not fear ending up paying more with a single subsidised class as the rates they pay will be determined by their income levels, not by ward class. So a patient earning $5,000 a month pays more for the same subsidised ward than a patient earning $1,000 a month.

In fact, the 1993 White Paper acknowledged that rationing by discomfort was not optimal, saying: 'The direct way to manage demand, which may eventually become necessary, is to use a means test.' At that time, means testing was an 'expensive and administratively clumsy procedure'. But it has become practical with today's technology and is already in place.

The next step is obvious: It is no longer necessary to impose levels of discomfort to distinguish wards with various levels of subsidy. Instead, one class of subsidised ward is all that is needed.

This would make for easier hospital construction. It is unlikely to add much to the building cost. Standard ward sizes and features make it easier for the nursing staff to carry out their duties.

It would also be administratively easier as hospitals will no longer need to explain the different features of a C, B2 or B2+ class ward. Instead, they need only tell patients the level of subsidy they are entitled to.

To be sure, the change from several to one subsidised class of hospital ward is a major move. It will take years, not least because existing wards will need to be reconfigured.

New hospitals can start doing this on a pilot basis. There will be difficulties and confusion during the transition, and patients will need to be re-educated.

But the effort will be worth it. Over time, wards will be smaller and self-contained. Subsidised patients will have access to hospital wards within their means that are also great from an infection control point of view.

salma@sph.com.sg

Friday, December 3, 2010

Cursing the blues in kingmaker state

Dec 3, 2010

In the last instalment of our series on how economic anxieties have affected ordinary Americans and the way they vote, we look at the 'kingmaker' state of Ohio, where polling results in last month's mid-terms could have a lasting effect on the Obama presidency.

By Paul Zach


As a lifelong Republican, Kelly frowns on government handouts: the political party he supports detests anything that smacks of 'socialism'.


But on Tuesday, the 36-year-old father of three turned up at the Parma Hunger Centre with his own hand held out.


For the first time in their lives, he and his wife, Chris, accepted a shopping cart overflowing with cartons of eggs, cans of spaghetti, a sack of Russet potatoes and other groceries, without paying for them.


'It feels like crap,' said Chris, 39.


'It doesn't feel good,' said Kelly. 'But if it feeds my kids... my kids are worth a lot more than my pride.'


Indeed, the couple are so mortified about their plight that they did not want their full names to be used or their pictures taken for this report.


Their decision to turn to a branch of the Hunger Network of Greater Cleveland, which relies in part on federal and local government subsidies as well as donations, came after another first in their 10 years of marriage: they have started receiving disconnection notices from utility companies just as the winter chill is setting in.


Chris said bills started piling up after she lost her job as a nurse in the nearly bankrupt school system of Parma 'a couple of years ago', and she had to see doctors about a medical condition they have yet to diagnose.


Her husband is the manager of a restaurant outlet in another city a long daily drive from their home. His salary is not enough for them to make ends meet.


'We went through all my retirement funds,' said Chris. 'The last couple of months I was counting change, buying groceries with change.'


Parma is a suburb that borders Cleveland, traditionally the most blue of Ohio's big cities. Located on the banks of Lake Erie, and fuelled by a legion of steel mills and auto factories in the early part of the last century, Cleveland was a magnet for hardworking immigrants. They joined unions and became solid supporters of Democratic Party politics.


When the steel and auto industries started leaving town in the 1960s, however, the population followed.


Over the past few months, years of corruption in government also saw federal charges filed against many of the most powerful Democrats in the Cuyahoga county government. Cleveland, the heart of the county, became the capital of the growing 'rust belt', an economic basket case unkindly called 'The Mistake on the Lake' - a long way from the days it billed itself as the 'Best Location in the Nation'.


Still, its legacy of supporting Democrats persists.


In 2008, the media projected that Mr Barack Obama would win the United States presidency for the Democrats as soon as it became clear that he had taken Ohio, with overwhelming support in Cleveland, even before vote counting had ended in most of the country.


Ohio has long been known as the 'kingmaker' in American politics - and not just because the state has sent the most number of natives to the White House. It has often been the key to victory in the presidential elections.


Political pundits thus viewed the decisive victory by Mr Obama in 2008, and that by Mr Ted Strickland for governor in 2006 - a win that ended 16 years of Republican domination in the post - as a sure sign that Democrats would rule Ohio, and thus the nation, for years to come.


Fast forward to this year.


Those same pundits now point to last month's mid-term election results in Ohio as a sure sign that Mr Obama will lose the state, and thus re-election to a second term, in 2012.


Mr Strickland is now a footnote. He became a one-term governor when he lost to Republican John Kasich, even though - although some would argue because - Mr Obama made more visits to Ohio to campaign for him than he did to any other state.


Mr Kasich is not going to be a regular governor in regular times.


When he takes over the post next month, he will have a direct hand in drawing Ohio's legislative districts next year as the head of the Apportionment Board.


That exercise - a once-in-10-years affair - involves the redrawing of electoral boundaries to reflect population changes.


The process has been criticised as a form of gerrymandering, and having a Republican in charge of the process means it markedly improves the party's chances of upending Mr Obama in Ohio, and - assuming history repeats itself - the country, in the next presidential election.


In the wake of the red tidal wave that swept Republicans into power in the US House of Representatives across the country on Nov 2, Ohio's Mr John Boehner, 61, was also elected the next Speaker of the House. He takes over from Democrat - and powerful Obama ally - Nancy Pelosi when the new Congress is sworn in next month.


So how did things come to this?


Put simply: jobs.


As states across the nation weathered the worst economic downturn since the Great Depression, hundreds of thousands of Ohioans lost their jobs during Mr Strickland's four years as governor.
The state's jobless rate was 5.5 per cent in September 2006, when only 328,000 were unemployed, according to Department of Job and Family Services data. By March this year, unemployment had doubled to a 26-year high of 11 per cent.


The final snapshot of Ohio's job market before election day last month showed the state's unemployment rate had improved to 10 per cent in September. That was too little, too late to save the jobs of Mr Strickland and many other Democrats in the state.


While the media loudly blamed the seismic shift on 'voter anger', Chris and Kelly looked more defeated than upset at politicians as they loaded their modest Chevy with groceries in the cold rain outside the Parma Hunger Centre.


In fact, Kelly did not even have time to vote for his Republican Party candidates; he wound up working from 5.30am until 8pm on election day, and did not get home until the polls had closed.
Mr Kevin O'Brien, the conservative columnist for The Plain Dealer, Cleveland's nationally respected newspaper, told The Straits Times that he blamed the Troubled Asset Relief Programme (Tarp) and 'Obamacare'.


He was referring to Mr Obama's decision to pour dollars that came out of the pockets of ordinary taxpayers into Tarp which rescued rich banks and financial institutions, and to focus on health-care reform rather than addressing the plight of Americans struggling to make ends meet.


'If the Democrats had waited two years to play for the big-government jackpot, they would not now be facing a huge turnover in state legislatures and governorships from November's election, which will lead to a decade of congressional districts drawn to suit Republicans,' he said.


'Tarp alone might not have cost the Democrats much, in Ohio or elsewhere. Forcing the issue on unpopular health-care reform will cost them for quite a while, though.'


Over at the Hunger Centre, Kelly refused to point fingers at either political party for his own problems, in effect showing his Republican side by accepting responsibility for them.


But he said: 'I've always noticed when the Republicans are in office, at the presidential level, I wind up making more. My raises are better. I take home more in my pay cheques.'


Sentiment like that, in a kingmaker state where making ends meet is more of a struggle than it usually is, and where Republicans hold the power to rezone polling districts, will mean the results of the mid-term elections could resonate all the way to 2012.


And Mr Obama may well pay the price then.


zach@sph.com.sg



Voters reject tax raise for schools


VOTERS in Ohio are so angry, they are willing to mortgage the future.


The instinctive Republican anti-tax mentality kicked in during last month's elections, and the target was schools.


During the polls, Parma voters rejected a tax increase for their city's public schools - for the seventh straight time. That will leave a system that is already on life support with a US$3.7 million (S$4.9 million) deficit next year.


In the Cleveland area alone, 41 school districts asked parents for more money to help them keep up with rising costs on the mid-term ballot on Nov 2. All but two went down in flames.
Foreign analysts wondering why the United States no longer leads in many areas of education need look no further than places like Parma.


The city has already slashed US$18 million from its budget and closed three primary schools. It has eliminated so many courses that students spend a large part of their school days in study halls, say some parents.


A campaign in the affluent Brecksville-Broadview Heights school district saw signs on lawns in both cities begging people to give their school system - which had been ranked third in the entire district - the thumbs up. No dice. Voters rejected calls for a school levy for the second straight time.


West of Cleveland, the city of Lorain has been begging residents to approve school funding for almost 20 years, to no avail. In last month's polls, 56 per cent of the residents again voted no.


Yet the tax increases asked for in such issues are far below tuition fees for private schools in the region. The suburb of Garfield Heights, for instance, asked for the area's biggest hike. It would have cost residents there another US$273 a year in property taxes per US$100,000 home valuation - and few homes there are worth that much.


Even in Hudson, a lush wealthy suburb south of Cleveland, people who can afford million-dollar mansions and Porsches refused to shell out another cent for their children's education.


They nixed a tax levy although the school district has already made US$8.8 million in budget cuts since 2006 and teachers agreed to freeze their wages.


In Medina, residents voted down a school levy for the third straight time.


Afterwards, the system's superintendent, Mr Randy Stepp, said: 'Based on my conversations with people, there's a lot of unhappiness out there with government, and the only place people really get a chance to voice their opinion is locally, which hits the schools.'


PAUL ZACH

SG & HK: Taxes and the Cost of living

Dec 3, 2010

Panel calls for S'pore to slash tax rates

Income tax should be cut to 17% to attract top talent, urge experts

By Yasmine Yahya


SINGAPORE should slash personal income tax rates if it wants to attract more top talent and share the country's economic success with local workers.

That is the view of tax experts who say that while Singapore's personal tax rates are lower than those of regional rivals such as China and Australia, high income earners still have to pay much higher taxes here than they would in Hong Kong.

'Our headline personal tax rate of 20 per cent is dismally short of closing the tax gap with Hong Kong, which has a flat rate of 15 per cent. Coupled with some significant deductions given in Hong Kong, such as home loan interest, Hong Kong's personal tax regime seems to have the upper hand,' said KPMG's head of international executive services, Mr Ooi Boon Jin.

For example, he said, a married individual earning US$2 million (S$2.6 million) would pay a tax of US$300,000 if he were living in Hong Kong. But in Singapore, his tax bill would amount to US$383,000.


The headline personal tax rate should be cut to at least 17 per cent, he said.

KPMG data shows that even if Singapore were to cut its headline rate to 17 per cent, those earning US$1 million or more would still be paying more taxes here than in Hong Kong. But the gap would be narrowed - a married individual earning US$2 million would now pay US$325,831 in income tax.

Ernst & Young international and corporate tax services partner Choo Eng Chuan agreed, saying that attracting more top executives would have a positive knock-on effect for the local population.

'Chief executive officers have a lot of people working under them. So if you attract the boss, you create employment for a lot of other people as well,' he said.

PricewaterhouseCoopers' international assignment services partner James Clemence, however, believes Singapore is already an extremely attractive location for talented executives and that reducing the top tax rates further would not necessarily draw more in.

It is more important for the Government to help middle income earners directly, he said.

'If the Government wanted to make changes to the income tax rates, I would suggest that they make adjustments to remove more taxpayers from the tax net altogether. For example, increasing the 0 per cent tax band from $20,000 of taxable income to $40,000 would remove more low earners from the burden of paying tax and save the tax authority the cost of collecting the relatively small amount of tax.'

Human resources experts also point out that the tax rate is not the most important factor that foreigners consider when choosing where to relocate.

'Lower tax rates mean higher disposable income, so that is one of the top factors. But people also want a place where their whole family can work, live and play. The career opportunities, education system and entertainment and social activities available are all considerations,' said solutions leader of talent consulting at Aon Hewitt, Mr Samir Bedi.

The division director for the financial services group at Robert Half International, Ms Stella Koh, agreed.

'Usually people would turn down one location for another because they have a more exciting job opportunity waiting for them at that other place. I have never heard of anyone turning Singapore down because its tax rate was higher than Hong Kong's.'

yasminey@sph.com.sg




Dec 3, 2010
Singapore now more expensive for expats

It moves from 9th to 8th position in Asia, and 79th to 42nd globally: Survey

By Yasmine Yahya

Living in Singapore is now more costly than Central London (50th position) but much cheaper than New York (39th position). -- ST FILE PHOTO

OVER the past six months, Singapore has become even more expensive for expatriates to live in, climbing from ninth spot in Asia to No. 8, said the latest cost of living survey from ECA International.

Rising prices and the strengthening of the Singapore dollar against major currencies propelled Singapore in the cost of living stakes from 79th position globally to 42nd over the past year.

That means it is more expensive for expatriates to live in Singapore than Central London which is ranked 50th worldwide, but not New York, which came in at No.39, based on ECA's latest twice-yearly survey, released yesterday.

However, it is not all doom and gloom. ECA International regional director for Asia Lee Quane said the rise in Singapore's cost of living is a double-edged sword.

'For companies bringing senior talent into Singapore, the cost of an assignment will increase as higher allowances are required to maintain employees' purchasing power. On the other hand, companies sending employees out of Singapore can apply lower cost of living allowances and still provide sufficient remuneration to maintain a good standard of living.'

The difference between the cost of living in Singapore and that of Hong Kong, the sixth most expensive city in Asia, is also rapidly narrowing, he noted. Two years ago there was a 15 per cent gap in the cost of living between Hong Kong and Singapore. This gap fell to 7 per cent a year ago and now stands at just 2 per cent.

TV producer Sha Liang, 23, who hails from the United States, told The Straits Times that she does feel that certain costs in Singapore are high. Her monthly rent, for example, takes up a third of her salary.

However, an expatriate's cost of living will largely depend on his or her lifestyle, she added. 'If you eat at hawker centres every day, that's affordable. But if you go out with friends a lot and go to nice restaurants, then those bills do add up quickly.'

Overall, Tokyo maintained its position as the most expensive location in Asia and worldwide for expatriates. In fact, ECA International noted that the gap between Tokyo and other locations in the region is widening: a year ago, the difference in cost of living between Tokyo and Hong Kong was 45 per cent. Today, it is 55 per cent.

Stronger currencies have led to HR managers having to increase their cost of living allowances for those in Seoul and Tokyo. Even in typically low-cost locations such as Bangkok and Jakarta, where the relative low cost of living has increased recently, HR managers are having to consider introducing allowances. Equally, the weakening of the euro has seen the cost of living in Dublin plunge.

Worldwide, Luanda in Angola was the second most expensive place after Tokyo. The Japanese city of Nagoya came third.

The survey calculates cost of living allowances for employees assigned around the world. It compiles data on allowances for goods and services consumed by them, such as food, drinks, tobacco and clothing.

yasminey@sph.com.sg


Most expensive Asian cities
1. Tokyo
2. Nagoya
3. Yokohama
4. Kobe
5. Seoul
6. Hong Kong
7. Shanghai
8. Singapore
9. Beijing
10. Busan

Thursday, December 2, 2010

A poem in a hdb playground

Dec 2, 2010

All it takes is one mum and Arthur Yap to spark the love of poetry

By Clara Chow

HEAT stroke, I dare say, is the least of worries for any spoken word artist.

Usually, there's the fear of being heckled by one's unruly audience in the middle of a poetry slam. The humiliation of being out-rhymed by a rival rhyme-meister or the ignominy of forgetting one's lines.

But few poetry reciters, like me, would be standing in the middle of a playground in Choa Chu Kang, in the middle of a blazing hot afternoon, preparing to open her mouth in front of two, gulp, hyperactive small boys with limited attention span.

Call it an experiment in service of poe-try: I was about to find out if it is indeed possible to introduce poetry - and post-modern, post-colonial poetry, at that - to preschoolers.

'Boys,' I announced, looking up at my four-year-old son Julian and his six-year-old pal Christopher, as they gazed with anticipation down at me from their crow's nest perch on the pirate boat-shaped playground equipment. 'I am about to read you a poem called '2 mothers in a hdb playground'.'

Christopher's mum, my fellow mother in the Housing Board playground, gave me an encouraging smile as she readied her camera to snap me in oratorical action. I took a deep breath. And began.

A bit of background is in order, on how I found myself in such a strange poem-reciting position. While other parents are busy hothousing their kids with reportedly genius learning methods, I like to use mine as literary guinea pigs, to find out whether it's possible to get them passionate about the pure sounds and playful syntax of verse.

After all, it is my belief that it is never too early to instil a love of poetry in children. If anything, poetry is simply there in our lives. It is there in the ta-dum, ta-dum beats of our hearts, the murmured lullabies before bedtime, the rocking motion of mother carrying child, and, cliched but true, the pitter-patter of little feet. Poetry is a game of language, and we all know how much young ones enjoy and learn through games.

Besides, poetry - while it never truly went away - is experiencing the kind of nerd-vogue that is behind the revival of old-school analog things such as typewriters, Atari machines and knitting. Just last month, Mr Scott Griffin, the founder of Canada's richest poetry prize, the Griffin Prize, announced that he was launching a bilingual poetry recital competition for high school students in his country. The C$10,000 (S$12,900) Poetry In Voices competition, which starts next year, will see students reciting both contemporary and classical poetry in English and French.

Last week, the shortlist for the inaugural Picador poetry prize was released, with a judge's enthusiastic pronouncement that it was 'a snapshot of a poetry in terrifically good health'. The 10 unpublished poets on the list ranged from a former forklift driver to an artist-gardener to a male model - a further nod to how cool and democratic poetry has become.

And recently, American writer Nicholson Baker's 2009 novel The Anthologist, a whimsical, metafictional treatise on poetry, managed to cut incisively through technical jargon like the iambic pentameter to herald the heroic beauty and pleasure of oft-heard stanzas for me. The time for introducing Junior to poetry is ripe.

Since Julian graduated from the babyish rhymes of Goodnight, Moon and Where The Wild Things Are some time ago, an age-appropriate poetry-shaped hole has appeared in his life, waiting to be filled. If poetry is a game and language a mental landscape, then whose landscape do I want my children to see in their mind's eye?

In Indian author Arundhati Roy's Booker Prize-winning novel The God Of Small Things, the headstrong, ill-fated mother in the narrative, Ammu, 'used Kipling to love her children before putting them to bed: We be of one blood, ye and I'. This emblem of poetic, if subconsciously Anglophiliac, maternal love moves me.

Better, I think, to start Julian on something he can relate to immediately. Something in his blood, in his ears - the Singlish of everyday speech, in the seminal poem '2 mothers in a hdb playground' by the late Singapore poet Arthur Yap.

For those who have not read this 1980 poem (and I confess, I discovered it only a few months ago, at a friend's recommendation), it is a playful imagining of a conversation between, well, two mothers in an HDB playground. In it, the mums compare their two sons in a subtle game of one-upwomanship ('ah beng is so smart/...your kim cheong is also quite smart,/what boy is he in the exam?') and talk about their terrazzo floors and Diethelm furniture, while calling out to their sons playing nearby.

In the two decades since the poem was written, much has changed. The playground I was preparing to read my poem in, for instance, was not made of mosaic tiles in dragon shapes. Christopher's mum and I are not as overtly kiasu as the mothers depicted. We worry less about force-feeding our sons the latest vitamins advertised on TV, more about nutritious, organic diets instead. Boys these days are also less likely to have names like 'Ah Beng'.

Standing in that playground, declaiming Yap's lines at the top of my voice as a few parents and domestic helpers looked on impassively from a distance, I tried to wrap my head around this and other little ironies and parallels. After a while, I realised that no one was batting an eyelid, and my mini, two-man audience was transfixed, because Yap's poetry had so perfectly captured the essence of how language is used here. From performing '2 mothers', I had unconsciously, unwittingly and easily slipped into the bodies and lives of those two mothers.

When I was done, the boys, who didn't even fidget once during my three-minute recital, clapped politely.

'Did you like it?' I asked, hopefully.

Yes, they answered genuinely (boys their age have yet to master the art of the diplomatic white lie).

'Can we go and play now?' asked my son.

I nodded and set them free.

clarac@sph.com.sg

Copyright © 2010 Singapore Press Holdings. All rights reserved.

The Fragile Community

November 29, 2010

By DAVID BROOKS

Julian Assange, the founder of WikiLeaks, had moved 37 times by the time he reached his 14th birthday. His mother didn’t enroll him in the local schools because, as Raffi Khatchadourian wrote in a New Yorker profile, she feared “that formal education would inculcate an unhealthy respect for authority.”

She needn’t have worried. As a young computer hacker, he formed a group called International Subversives. As an adult, he wrote “Conspiracy as Governance,” a pseudo-intellectual online diatribe. He talks of vast “patronage networks” that constrain the human spirit.

Far from respecting authority, Assange seems to be an old-fashioned anarchist who believes that all ruling institutions are corrupt and public pronouncements are lies.

For someone with his mind-set, the decision to expose secrets is easy. If the hidden world is suspect, then everything should be revealed. As The New Yorker reported, WikiLeaks has published technical details about an Army device designed to prevent roadside bombs from detonating. It posted soldiers’ Social Security numbers. This week, the group celebrated the release of internal State Department documents with a triumphalist statement claiming that the documents expose the corruption, hypocrisy and venality of U.S. diplomats.

For him, it’s easy. But for everyone else, it’s hard. My colleagues on the news side of this newspaper do not share Assange’s mentality. As the various statements from the editors have made abundantly clear, they face a much thornier set of issues.

As journalists, they have a professional obligation to share information that might help people make informed decisions. That means asking questions like: How does the U.S. government lobby allies? What is the real nature of our relationship with Pakistani intelligence? At the same time, as humans and citizens, my colleagues know they have a moral obligation not to endanger lives or national security.

The Times has thus erected a series of filters between the 250,000 raw documents that WikiLeaks obtained and complete public exposure. The paper has released only a tiny percentage of the cables. Information that might endanger informants has been redacted. Specific cables have been put into context with broader reporting.

Yet it might be useful to consider one more filter. Consider it the World Order filter. The fact that we live our lives amid order and not chaos is the great achievement of civilization. This order should not be taken for granted.

This order is tenuously maintained by brave soldiers but also by talkative leaders and diplomats. Every second of every day, leaders and diplomats are engaged in a never-ending conversation. The leaked cables reveal this conversation. They show diplomats seeking information, cajoling each other and engaging in faux-friendships and petty hypocrisies as they seek to avoid global disasters.

Despite the imaginings of people like Assange, the conversation revealed in the cables is not devious and nefarious. The private conversation is similar to the public conversation, except maybe more admirable. Israeli and Arab diplomats can be seen reacting sympathetically and realistically toward one another. The Americans in the cables are generally savvy and honest. Iran’s neighbors are properly alarmed and reaching out.

Some people argue that this diplomatic conversation is based on mechanical calculations about national self-interest, and it won’t be affected by public exposure. But this conversation, like all conversations, is built on relationships. The quality of the conversation is determined by the level of trust. Its direction is influenced by persuasion and by feelings about friends and enemies.
The quality of the conversation is damaged by exposure, just as our relationships with our neighbors would be damaged if every private assessment were brought to the light of day. We’ve seen what happens when conversations deteriorate (look at the U.S. Congress), and it’s ugly.

The WikiLeaks dump will probably damage the global conversation. Nations will be less likely to share with the United States. Agencies will be tempted to return to the pre-9/11 silos. World leaders will get their back up when they read what is said about them. Cooperation against Iran may be harder to maintain because Arab leaders feel exposed and boxed in. This fragile international conversation is under threat. It’s under threat from WikiLeaks. It’s under threat from a Gresham’s Law effect, in which the level of public exposure is determined by the biggest leaker and the biggest traitor.

It should be possible to erect a filter that protects not only lives and operations but also international relationships. It should be possible to do articles on specific revelations — Is the U.S. using diplomats to spy on the U.N.? What missile technology did North Korea give to Iran? — without unveiling in a wholesale manner the nuts and bolts of the diplomatic enterprise. We depend on those human conversations for the limited order we enjoy every day.

An excerpt of a conversation between David Brooks and another NYT columnist, Gail Collins:
http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/12/01/have-we-learned-anything-from-the-leaked-cables/

David Brooks: Maybe the good news is that there is no news. I’ve asked a few world leaders if the secret information they have access to gives them a different picture of the world than the one the rest of us get just reading the paper. They generally say no. What we see on the outside is what they see on the inside. They just have more granularity.

Gail Collins: Yes, so far I’ve been amazed by how few surprises we’ve gotten. Unless you were under the impression that the other Arab countries didn’t hate Iran. Or that China wasn’t fully aware that the leadership of North Korea is entirely composed of nutballs.

David Brooks: These cables — which don’t include “top secret” stuff, admittedly — show no hidden conspiracies, at least of any consequence. Maybe the normal work of journalism covers the world as it really is.

Gail Collins: And that’s a thought that will make the folks at WikiLeaks very depressed.